Desai Rani A, Harpaz-Rotem Ilan, Najavits Lisa M, Rosenheck Robert A
Northeast Program Evaluation Center, Department of Veterans Affairs Connecticut Healthcare System(182), 950 Campbell Ave., West Haven, CT 06516, USA.
Psychiatr Serv. 2008 Sep;59(9):996-1003. doi: 10.1176/ps.2008.59.9.996.
Seeking Safety is a manualized cognitive-behavioral therapy intervention that is designed to treat clients with comorbid substance abuse and trauma histories. This study examined its effectiveness when used with homeless women veterans with psychiatric or substance abuse problems at 11 Department of Veterans Affairs medical centers that had Homeless Women Veterans Programs.
The intervention consists of 25 sessions that cover topics to help build safety in clients' lives and is present-focused, offering psychoeducation and coping skills. A cohort of homeless women veterans (N=359) was recruited before Seeking Safety was implemented (phase I). After clinicians were trained and certified in Seeking Safety, a postimplementation cohort was recruited and offered Seeking Safety treatment (phase II, N=91). Phase I lasted from January 2000 to June 2003. Phase II lasted from June 2003 to December 2005. The intervention lasted for six months. All participants were interviewed every three months for one year and received intensive case management and other services during the study. Mixed models were used to compare one-year clinical outcomes across phases.
There were few differences across groups at baseline. All women entering the Homeless Women Veterans Programs showed significant improvement on most clinical outcome measures over one year. The Seeking Safety cohort reported significantly better outcomes over one year in employment, social support, general symptoms of psychiatric distress, and symptoms of posttraumatic stress disorder, particularly in the avoidance and arousal clusters. However, the Seeking Safety cohort was significantly more likely to have used drugs in the past 30 days.
Seeking Safety appears to have had a moderately beneficial impact on several clinical outcomes. Although the nonequivalent comparison groups and low follow-up rates limit the internal validity of these results, availability of Seeking Safety may be of benefit for homeless female veterans. It is noteworthy that it could be delivered and implemented by case managers with little or no prior counseling experience.
“寻求安全”是一种标准化的认知行为疗法干预措施,旨在治疗同时患有药物滥用和创伤史的患者。本研究考察了在11家设有退伍军人事务部无家可归女性退伍军人项目的医疗中心,该疗法用于治疗有精神疾病或药物滥用问题的无家可归女性退伍军人时的有效性。
该干预包括25节课程,涵盖帮助患者在生活中建立安全感的主题,且以当下为重点,提供心理教育和应对技巧。在实施“寻求安全”疗法之前(第一阶段),招募了一批无家可归女性退伍军人(N = 359)。在临床医生接受“寻求安全”疗法的培训并获得认证后,招募了一个实施后队列并为其提供“寻求安全”治疗(第二阶段,N = 91)。第一阶段从2000年1月持续到2003年6月。第二阶段从2003年6月持续到2005年12月。干预持续六个月。所有参与者在一年中每三个月接受一次访谈,并在研究期间接受强化个案管理和其他服务。使用混合模型比较各阶段的一年临床结果。
基线时各组之间差异不大。所有进入无家可归女性退伍军人项目的女性在一年中的大多数临床结果指标上都有显著改善。“寻求安全”队列在就业、社会支持、精神痛苦的一般症状和创伤后应激障碍症状方面,尤其是在回避和唤醒集群方面,报告的一年结果明显更好。然而,“寻求安全”队列在过去30天内使用药物的可能性明显更高。
“寻求安全”疗法似乎对几个临床结果产生了适度有益的影响。尽管非等效比较组和低随访率限制了这些结果的内部有效性,但“寻求安全”疗法的可用性可能对无家可归的女性退伍军人有益。值得注意的是,它可以由几乎没有或没有先前咨询经验的个案管理员提供和实施。