Pandey Juhi, Verbalis Alyssa, Robins Diana L, Boorstein Hilary, Klin A M I, Babitz Tammy, Chawarska Katarzyna, Volkmar Fred, Green James, Barton Marianne, Fein Deborah
University of Connecticut, Storrs, Connecticut 06269, USA.
Autism. 2008 Sep;12(5):513-35. doi: 10.1177/1362361308094503.
The Modified Checklist for Autism in Toddlers (M-CHAT) was used to screen younger (16-23 months) versus older (24-30 months) high- and low-risk toddlers. Refusal rates for follow-up interview showed no group differences, but parents of younger/low-risk children were more likely to refuse evaluation than parents of high-risk children. PPP for an ASD diagnosis was: younger/high-risk 0.79, older/high-risk 0.74, younger/low-risk 0.28, and older/low-risk 0.61, with PPP differing by age within the low-risk group. Most of the children in all groups, however, were diagnosed with a developmental disorder. Symptom severity generally did not differ among groups. Cognitive and adaptive measures showed minimal group differences. Therefore, older and younger toddlers had similar symptomatology and developmental delays; PPP for ASD is better at 24 than 18 months for low-risk children; however, these children are still highly likely to show a developmental disorder. Clinical decision making should balance early identification against the lower specificity of M-CHAT screening for the younger/low-risk group.
改良幼儿孤独症筛查量表(M-CHAT)用于筛查年龄较小(16 - 23个月)和年龄较大(24 - 30个月)的高风险与低风险幼儿。随访访谈的拒绝率在各群体间无差异,但年龄较小/低风险儿童的家长比高风险儿童的家长更有可能拒绝评估。孤独症谱系障碍(ASD)诊断的阳性预测值(PPP)分别为:年龄较小/高风险0.79,年龄较大/高风险0.74,年龄较小/低风险0.28,年龄较大/低风险0.61,低风险组内PPP因年龄而异。然而,所有组中的大多数儿童被诊断为发育障碍。症状严重程度在各群体间通常无差异。认知和适应性测量显示群体差异极小。因此,年龄较大和较小的幼儿有相似的症状和发育迟缓;对于低风险儿童,24个月时ASD的PPP比18个月时更好;然而,这些儿童仍极有可能表现出发育障碍。临床决策应在早期识别与M-CHAT对年龄较小/低风险组筛查较低特异性之间进行权衡。