Hagel L M, Pickett W, Pahwa P, Day L, Brison R J, Marlenga B, Crowe T, Snodgrass P, Ulmer K, Dosman J A
Canadian Centre for Health and Safety in Agriculture, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Canada.
Inj Prev. 2008 Oct;14(5):290-5. doi: 10.1136/ip.2008.018515.
To evaluate the effectiveness of an agricultural health and safety program in reducing risks of injury.
Cross-sectional survey.
50 rural municipalities in the Province of Saskatchewan, Canada.
The Agricultural Health and Safety Network (AHSN), a mainly educational program that administered 112 farm safety interventions over 19 years.
5292 farm people associated with 2392 Saskatchewan farms. Farms and associated farm people were categorized into three groups according to years of participation in the AHSN.
self-reported prevalence of: (1) farm safety practices; (2) physical farm hazards.
(1) self-reported agricultural injuries.
After adjustment for group imbalances and clustering at the rural municipality level, the prevalence of all impact and outcome measures was not significantly different on farms grouped according to years of AHSN participation. To illustrate, the adjusted relative risk of reporting no rollover protection on tractors among farms with none (0 years) versus high (>8 years) levels of AHSN participation was 0.95 (95% CI 0.69 to 1.30). The adjusted relative risk for agricultural injuries (all types) reported for the year before the survey was 0.99 (95% CI 0.74 to 1.32).
Educational interventions delivered via the AHSN program were not associated with observable differences in farm safety practices, physical farm hazards, or farm-related injury outcomes. There is a need for the agricultural sector to extend the scope of its injury prevention initiatives to include the full public health model of education, engineering, and regulation.
评估一项农业健康与安全计划在降低受伤风险方面的有效性。
横断面调查。
加拿大萨斯喀彻温省的50个农村自治市。
农业健康与安全网络(AHSN),这是一项主要的教育计划,在19年里实施了112项农场安全干预措施。
与萨斯喀彻温省2392个农场相关的5292名农场人员。根据参与AHSN的年限,农场及相关农场人员被分为三组。
自我报告的(1)农场安全实践;(2)农场物理危害的流行情况。
(1)自我报告的农业伤害情况。
在对农村自治市层面的组间不均衡和聚类进行调整后,根据AHSN参与年限分组的农场在所有影响和结果指标的流行情况上没有显著差异。举例来说,在AHSN参与年限为零(0年)与高(>8年)的农场中,报告拖拉机无翻车保护的调整相对风险为0.95(95%可信区间0.69至1.30)。调查前一年报告的所有类型农业伤害的调整相对风险为0.99(95%可信区间0.74至1.32)。
通过AHSN计划实施的教育干预措施与农场安全实践、农场物理危害或与农场相关的伤害结果的可观察差异无关。农业部门需要扩大其伤害预防举措的范围,将教育、工程和监管的完整公共卫生模式纳入其中。