O'Connor P G, Gottlieb L D, Kraus M L, Segal S R, Horwitz R I
Department of Medicine, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, CT 06510.
J Gen Intern Med. 1991 Jul-Aug;6(4):312-6. doi: 10.1007/BF02597427.
To identify patient features--both social and clinical--that may be associated with treatment failure in outpatient alcohol withdrawal.
A prospective observational cohort study of patients who underwent outpatient management of the alcohol withdrawal syndrome.
Community hospital-based outpatient alcohol treatment program.
The 179 patients who were eligible for and participated in a clinical trial of drug therapy for outpatient management of the alcohol withdrawal syndrome.
Treatment failure occurred for 45% (80/179) of the patients. Failure rating did not vary according to diverse sociodemographic features such as age, level of education, income, medical insurance status, and marital status. Persons who were homeless did as well as those who were not. In contrast, two clinical features of withdrawal were associated with significantly higher rates of treatment failure: craving and withdrawal symptom severity. High cravers had a treatment failure rate of 56% (22/39), compared with 36% (41/115) for those with lower scores (p less than 0.03). Among those with moderate-to-high withdrawal symptom severity, 49% (74/151) represented treatment failures, compared with 22% (6/27) of those in the low-symptom group (p less than 0.01).
While these data do not confirm that socially disadvantaged persons are at increased risk for withdrawal treatment failure, two clinical features--craving and withdrawal symptom severity--may help identify high-risk patients.
确定可能与门诊酒精戒断治疗失败相关的患者特征,包括社会特征和临床特征。
对接受门诊酒精戒断综合征管理的患者进行前瞻性观察队列研究。
社区医院门诊酒精治疗项目。
179名符合条件并参与门诊酒精戒断综合征药物治疗临床试验的患者。
45%(80/179)的患者治疗失败。失败率并未因年龄、教育程度、收入、医疗保险状况和婚姻状况等不同社会人口学特征而有所不同。无家可归者与有家可归者的情况相同。相比之下,戒断的两个临床特征与显著更高的治疗失败率相关:渴望和戒断症状严重程度。高渴望者的治疗失败率为56%(22/39),而得分较低者为36%(41/115)(p<0.03)。在戒断症状严重程度为中度至高度的患者中,49%(74/151)治疗失败,而低症状组为22%(6/27)(p<0.01)。
虽然这些数据并未证实社会弱势群体在戒断治疗失败方面风险增加,但渴望和戒断症状严重程度这两个临床特征可能有助于识别高危患者。