Lee Stephanie J, Astigarraga Claudia C, Eapen Mary, Artz Andrew S, Davies Stella M, Champlin Richard, Jagasia Madan, Kernan Nancy A, Loberiza Fausto R, Bevans Margaret, Soiffer Robert J, Joffe Steven
Division of Clinical Research, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, Seattle, Washington 98109, USA.
Biol Blood Marrow Transplant. 2008 Nov;14(11):1231-8. doi: 10.1016/j.bbmt.2008.08.008.
Hematopoietic cell transplantation is an elective procedure that results in prolonged immune suppression and high treatment-related morbidity and mortality. Transplant centers and physicians use a variety of prophylaxis and monitoring strategies to prevent or minimize complications. Little is known about the variability in these practices. We conducted an international Internet-based survey of 526 physicians to describe the spectrum of supportive care practices employed. Consistency in pretransplant cardiac (96%) and pulmonary (95%) screening, informed consent documentation (93%), and use of antifungal prophylaxis (92%) was observed. Greater heterogeneity was seen in use of myelogenous growth factors, empiric antibiotic therapy, protective isolation procedures, posttransplant monitoring, and environmental and social restrictions. Although some practice differences were associated with physician characteristics and transplant type, most practice variation remained unexplained. These results suggest a need for well-designed observational and interventional studies to provide data about which supportive care practices improve outcomes. For practices proved to be beneficial, publication of guidelines and incorporation of monitoring into quality improvement initiatives may help standardize practices.
造血细胞移植是一种选择性治疗手段,会导致长期免疫抑制以及较高的治疗相关发病率和死亡率。移植中心和医生采用多种预防和监测策略来预防并发症或使其降至最低。对于这些做法的差异了解甚少。我们对526名医生进行了一项基于互联网的国际调查,以描述所采用的支持性护理做法的范围。观察到移植前心脏(96%)和肺部(95%)筛查、知情同意文件记录(93%)以及抗真菌预防措施的使用(92%)具有一致性。在使用骨髓生长因子、经验性抗生素治疗、保护性隔离程序、移植后监测以及环境和社会限制方面存在更大的异质性。虽然一些做法差异与医生特征和移植类型有关,但大多数做法差异仍无法解释。这些结果表明需要进行精心设计的观察性和干预性研究,以提供关于哪些支持性护理做法能改善预后的数据。对于已被证明有益的做法,发布指南并将监测纳入质量改进举措可能有助于规范做法。