O'Toole Joanne, Sinclair Martha, Leder Karin
Department of Epidemiology and Preventive Medicine, Monash University, The Alfred, Melbourne, Victoria 3004, Australia.
BMC Med Res Methodol. 2008 Nov 3;8:71. doi: 10.1186/1471-2288-8-71.
Epidemiological and other studies that require participants to respond by completing a questionnaire face the growing threat of non-response. Response rates to household telephone surveys are diminishing because of changes in telecommunications, marketing and culture. Accordingly, updated information is required about the rate of telephone listing in directories and optimal strategies to maximise survey participation.
A total of 3426 households in Sydney, Australia were approached to participate in a computer assisted telephone interview (CATI) regarding their domestic (recycled and/or drinking) water usage. Only randomly selected households in the suburb and postcode of interest with a telephone number listed in the Electronic White Pages (EWP) that matched Australian electoral records were approached.
The CATI response rate for eligible households contacted by telephone was 39%. The rate of matching of electoral and EWP records, a measure of telephone directory coverage, was 55%.
The use of a combination of approaches, such as an advance letter, interviewer training, establishment of researcher credentials, increasing call attempts and targeted call times, remains a good strategy to maximise telephone response rates. However, by way of preparation for future technological changes, reduced telephone number listings and people's increasing resistance to unwanted phone calls, alternatives to telephone surveys, such as internet-based approaches, should be investigated.
要求参与者通过填写问卷进行回应的流行病学及其他研究面临着无回应问题日益严重的威胁。由于电信、营销和文化方面的变化,家庭电话调查的回应率正在下降。因此,需要有关电话号码在电话簿中的登记率以及使调查参与度最大化的最佳策略的最新信息。
在澳大利亚悉尼,共有3426户家庭被邀请参与一项关于其家庭(再生水和/或饮用水)用水情况的计算机辅助电话访谈(CATI)。仅对位于感兴趣的郊区和邮政编码区域、电话号码列在与澳大利亚选举记录匹配的电子白页(EWP)中的随机选择的家庭进行了邀请。
通过电话联系的符合条件家庭的CATI回应率为39%。选举记录与EWP记录的匹配率(衡量电话簿覆盖范围的指标)为55%。
采用多种方法相结合,如预先信函、访员培训、确立研究人员资质、增加呼叫尝试次数以及设定有针对性的呼叫时间,仍然是使电话回应率最大化的良好策略。然而,为应对未来的技术变革、电话号码登记减少以及人们对不必要电话呼叫的抵触情绪增加等情况,应研究电话调查的替代方法,如基于互联网的方法。