Reames Jeff, Handel Daniel A, Al-Assaf A, Hedges Jerris R
Department of Emergency Medicine, Mercy Health Center, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, USA.
J Emerg Med. 2009 Aug;37(2):172-6. doi: 10.1016/j.jemermed.2007.12.040. Epub 2008 Nov 12.
A paucity of board-certified Emergency Physicians practice in rural Emergency Departments (EDs). One proposed solution has been to train residents in rural EDs to increase the likelihood that they would continue to practice in rural EDs. Some within academic Emergency Medicine question whether rural hospital EDs can provide adequate patient volume for training an Emergency Medicine (EM) resident.
To compare per-physician patient-volumes in rural vs. urban hospital EDs in Oklahoma (OK) and the proportion of board-certified EM physicians in these two ED settings.
A 21-question survey was distributed to all OK hospital ED directors. Analysis was limited to non-military hospitals with EDs having an annual census > 15,000 patient visits. Comparisons were made between rural and urban EDs.
There were 37 hospitals included in the analysis. Urban EDs had a higher proportion of board-certified EM physicians than rural EDs (80% vs. 28%). There were 4359 vs. 4470 patients seen per physician FTE (full-time equivalent) in the rural vs. urban ED settings, respectively (p = 0.84).
Patient volumes per physician FTE do not differ in rural vs. urban OK hospital EDs, suggesting that an adequate volume of patients exists in rural EDs to support EM resident education. Proportionately fewer board-certified Emergency Physicians staff rural EDs. Opportunities to increase rural ED-based EM resident training should be explored.
农村急诊科(ED)中具备委员会认证的急诊医师数量不足。一种提议的解决方案是在农村急诊科培训住院医师,以增加他们继续在农村急诊科执业的可能性。一些学术急诊医学领域的人士质疑农村医院急诊科是否能提供足够的患者数量来培训急诊医学(EM)住院医师。
比较俄克拉荷马州(OK)农村和城市医院急诊科每位医师的患者数量,以及这两种急诊科环境中获得委员会认证的急诊医师比例。
向俄克拉荷马州所有医院急诊科主任发放了一份包含21个问题的调查问卷。分析仅限于年就诊量超过15000人次且设有急诊科的非军事医院。对农村和城市急诊科进行了比较。
分析纳入了37家医院。城市急诊科获得委员会认证的急诊医师比例高于农村急诊科(80%对28%)。农村和城市急诊科每位全时当量(FTE)医师的就诊患者分别为4359人和4470人(p = 0.84)。
俄克拉荷马州农村和城市医院急诊科每位FTE医师的患者数量没有差异,这表明农村急诊科有足够数量的患者来支持急诊医学住院医师教育。农村急诊科配备的获得委员会认证的急诊医师比例相对较少。应探索增加基于农村急诊科的急诊医学住院医师培训的机会。