Fothergill D M, Hedges D, Morrison J B
School of Kinesiology, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby B.C., Canada.
Undersea Biomed Res. 1991 Jan;18(1):1-19.
This study examined N2 and CO2 components of narcosis by comparing the effects of three levels of PETCO2 [low = 29 mmHg (SD = 4 mmHg), medium = 47 mmHg (SD = 1 mmHg), high = 57 mmHg (SD = 2 mmHg)] at 1 and 6 atm abs in 12 male volunteers. Cognitive and psychomotor performances were examined using a variety of tasks, including a modified Stroop test, an arithmetic test, number comparison, a figure copying test, and the Purdue pegboard test. Performance on all tasks demonstrated significant (P less than 0.05) decrements at 6 atm abs. High CO2 tensions significantly impaired cognitive and psychomotor performance at 1 atm abs and caused further decrements at 6 atm abs (P less than 0.05). However, no significant N2-CO2 interaction (P greater than 0.05) or global threshold for the onset of CO2 narcosis was indicated by the test scores. The pattern of intratest results were different for N2 and CO2. At high PETCO2, performance deficits were due to a slowing of performance rather than a disruption of the accuracy of processing. Nitrogen narcosis, conversely, produced significant impairment through both decreases in the speed and accuracy of processing on the majority of performance tests. It was concluded that within the PETCO2 ranges studied: a) PETCO2 and PIN2 are additive in their effects on impaired cognitive and psychomotor performance at depth; b) high PETCO2 and PIN2 induce distinctly different strategic responses on the speed accuracy trade-off function of the performance tests; c) decrements in cognitive and psychomotor performance under high PETCO2 do not conform to the predicted narcotic potency of CO2 according to the lipid solubility theory of narcosis.
本研究通过比较12名男性志愿者在1个绝对大气压和6个绝对大气压下三种呼气末二氧化碳分压水平[低 = 29 mmHg(标准差 = 4 mmHg),中 = 47 mmHg(标准差 = 1 mmHg),高 = 57 mmHg(标准差 = 2 mmHg)]对麻醉的氮气和二氧化碳成分的影响。使用多种任务对认知和心理运动表现进行检测,包括改良的斯特鲁普测试、算术测试、数字比较、图形临摹测试和普渡钉板测试。在6个绝对大气压下,所有任务的表现均出现显著(P < 0.05)下降。高二氧化碳分压在1个绝对大气压下显著损害认知和心理运动表现,并在6个绝对大气压下导致进一步下降(P < 0.05)。然而,测试分数未显示出显著的氮气 - 二氧化碳相互作用(P > 0.05)或二氧化碳麻醉开始的总体阈值。氮气和二氧化碳的测试内结果模式不同。在高呼气末二氧化碳分压时,表现缺陷是由于表现速度减慢而非处理准确性的破坏。相反,在大多数表现测试中,氮麻醉通过处理速度和准确性的降低产生显著损害。研究得出结论,在所研究的呼气末二氧化碳分压范围内:a)呼气末二氧化碳分压和吸入氮气分压对深度时受损的认知和心理运动表现的影响具有相加性;b)高呼气末二氧化碳分压和吸入氮气分压在表现测试的速度准确性权衡功能上诱导明显不同的策略反应;c)高呼气末二氧化碳分压下认知和心理运动表现的下降不符合根据麻醉的脂溶性理论预测的二氧化碳麻醉效能。