Larkey Linda K, Lopez Ana Maria, Minnal Archana, Gonzalez Julie
Department of Family and Community Medicine, University of Arizona College of Medicine, Arizona Cancer Center, Scottsdale, AZ 85258, USA.
Cancer Control. 2009 Jan;16(1):79-87. doi: 10.1177/107327480901600112.
In a low socioeconomic-status population of Latina women, we evaluated the potential of storytelling (ST) as a culturally aligned narrative method to promote colorectal cancer (CRC) prevention and screening, compared to a risk tool (RT)-based intervention.
Seventy-eight women were randomized in this pilot study to one of two brief interventions to communicate CRC risk reduction options: ST or an RT. Measures of behavioral intentions relative to CRC prevention and screening were obtained following the intervention.
Mean scores for intent to obtain and recommend endoscopy to others were significantly better for participants receiving ST than RT (P = .038 and P = .011, respectively). All participants expressed intent to increase fruit and vegetable consumption and physical activity in response to interventions. Post-intervention perceptions of cancer risk and fear of CRC were not significantly different for participants receiving ST compared with RT. Pre- to post-intervention perceptions of risk increased in ST and decreased in RT, while decreases in fear were similar across both intervention groups.
Storytelling may be an effective approach for changing CRC risk-related behavioral intentions among Latinas. Mediating factors (such as perceived risk or fear) often used to predict behavior change may not adequately explain the potential persuasive mechanisms of storytelling.
在社会经济地位较低的拉丁裔女性群体中,我们评估了讲故事(ST)作为一种文化契合的叙事方法促进结直肠癌(CRC)预防和筛查的潜力,并与基于风险工具(RT)的干预措施进行了比较。
在这项试点研究中,78名女性被随机分配到两种简短干预措施之一,以传达降低CRC风险的选择:ST或RT。干预后获得了与CRC预防和筛查相关的行为意图测量值。
接受ST的参与者在获取并向他人推荐内镜检查的意图方面的平均得分显著高于接受RT的参与者(分别为P = 0.038和P = 0.011)。所有参与者均表示有意在干预后增加水果和蔬菜的摄入量以及体育活动。接受ST的参与者与接受RT的参与者相比,干预后对癌症风险的认知和对CRC的恐惧没有显著差异。干预前到干预后,ST组的风险认知增加,RT组的风险认知降低,而两个干预组的恐惧降低情况相似。
讲故事可能是改变拉丁裔女性中与CRC风险相关行为意图的有效方法。常用于预测行为改变的中介因素(如感知风险或恐惧)可能无法充分解释讲故事的潜在说服机制。