Ehlen Leslie A, Marshall Teresa A, Qian Fang, Wefel James S, Warren John J
College of Dentistry, University of Iowa, USA.
Nutr Res. 2008 May;28(5):299-303. doi: 10.1016/j.nutres.2008.03.001.
Acidic beverages are thought to increase the potential for dental erosion. We report pH and titratable acidities (ie, quantity of base required to bring a solution to neutral pH) of beverages popular in the United States and lesion depths in enamel and root surfaces after beverage exposure, and we describe associations among pH, titratable acidity, and both enamel and root erosive lesion depths. The pH of 100% juices, regular sodas, diet sodas, and sports drinks upon opening and the titratable acidity both upon opening and after 60 minutes of stirring were measured. Enamel and root surfaces of healthy permanent molars and premolars were exposed to individual beverages (4 enamel and 4 root surfaces per beverage) for 25 hours, and erosion was measured. Statistical analyses included 2-sample t tests, analyses of variance with post hoc Tukey studentized range test; and Spearman rank correlation coefficients. All beverages were acidic; the titratable acidity of energy drinks was greater than that of regular and diet sodas that were greater than that of 100% juices and sports drinks (P < .05). Enamel lesion depths after beverage exposures were greatest for Gatorade, followed by those for Red Bull and Coke that were greater than those for Diet Coke and 100% apple juice (P < .05). Root lesion depths were greatest for Gatorade, followed by Red Bull, Coke, 100% apple juice, and Diet Coke (P < .05). Lesion depths were not associated with pH or titratable acidity. Beverages popular in the United States can produce dental erosion.
酸性饮料被认为会增加牙齿侵蚀的可能性。我们报告了美国流行饮料的pH值和可滴定酸度(即将溶液调至中性pH值所需的碱量),以及饮料接触后牙釉质和牙根表面的病变深度,并描述了pH值、可滴定酸度与牙釉质和牙根侵蚀性病变深度之间的关联。测量了100%果汁、普通汽水、无糖汽水和运动饮料开封时的pH值以及开封时和搅拌60分钟后的可滴定酸度。将健康恒牙磨牙和前磨牙的牙釉质和牙根表面暴露于每种饮料中(每种饮料4个牙釉质和4个牙根表面)25小时,并测量侵蚀情况。统计分析包括两样本t检验、方差分析及事后Tukey学生化极差检验;以及Spearman等级相关系数。所有饮料均呈酸性;能量饮料的可滴定酸度高于普通汽水和无糖汽水,普通汽水和无糖汽水高于100%果汁和运动饮料(P < 0.05)。饮料接触后,佳得乐导致的牙釉质病变深度最大,其次是红牛和可乐,它们大于健怡可乐和100%苹果汁(P < 0.05)。佳得乐导致的牙根病变深度最大,其次是红牛、可乐、100%苹果汁和健怡可乐(P < 0.05)。病变深度与pH值或可滴定酸度无关。美国流行的饮料会导致牙齿侵蚀。