Hidasi Eszter, Diószeghy Péter, Csépány Tünde, Mechler Ferenc, Bereczki Dániel
Department of Neurology, University of Debrecen, Health Science and Medical Center, Debrecen, Hungary.
Med Hypotheses. 2009 May;72(5):562-6. doi: 10.1016/j.mehy.2008.07.066. Epub 2009 Jan 19.
Multiple sclerosis (MS) is primarily a disease of the central nervous system. Although the involvement of the peripheral nervous system in MS was suggested over 100 years ago, the issue is still controversial, and it is generally accepted that except for the optic nerve the peripheral nerves are left unaffected by the disease. We hypothesize, that an electroneurographical study if thorough enough, may reveal differences in some nerve conduction parameters between MS patients and healthy subjects. Second, we assume that the sensitivity of nerve conduction measurements might be increased if performed at a range of temperatures, reflecting a differential effect of cooling and warming on the peripheral nerve conduction parameters in MS patients and controls. Finally, we expect that the differences in these parameters between controls and MS patients will increase with the progression of the disease. To test these hypotheses in a pilot study, we performed a detailed analysis of the motor and sensory nerve conduction features of the right median nerve in 13 MS patients and 13 controls at 5 degrees C increments between 20 and 40 degrees C, and repeated these measurements after 3 years. The motor latencies were 0.3-0.6 ms longer in MS patients compared to the controls both initially and 3 years later (0.058<p<0.09). The durations and areas of the compound motor action potential (CMAP) appeared more sensitive to changes in temperature in the MS group (0.057<p<0.1). The change in both distal motor latency and sensory latency per unit change in temperature decreased significantly in 3 years within the MS but not in the control group. These results suggest a mild and progressive involvement of the PNS in MS. Most differences in this pilot study were on the border of statistical significance therefore our hypotheses should be confirmed in studies with larger sample size.
多发性硬化症(MS)主要是一种中枢神经系统疾病。尽管100多年前就有人提出MS会累及周围神经系统,但这个问题仍存在争议,目前普遍认为除视神经外,周围神经不受该疾病影响。我们推测,如果进行足够全面的神经电生理研究,可能会发现MS患者与健康受试者在某些神经传导参数上存在差异。其次,我们假设如果在一系列温度下进行神经传导测量,其敏感性可能会提高,这反映了冷却和升温对MS患者及对照组周围神经传导参数的不同影响。最后,我们预计对照组与MS患者之间这些参数的差异会随着疾病进展而增大。为在一项初步研究中检验这些假设,我们对13例MS患者和13名对照者的右侧正中神经运动和感觉神经传导特征进行了详细分析,测量温度范围为20至40摄氏度,每隔5摄氏度递增一次,并在3年后重复这些测量。最初及3年后,MS患者的运动潜伏期均比对照组长0.3 - 0.6毫秒(0.058 < p < 0.09)。复合运动动作电位(CMAP)的持续时间和面积在MS组中似乎对温度变化更敏感(0.057 < p < 0.1)。在MS组中,3年内温度每变化一个单位时,远端运动潜伏期和感觉潜伏期的变化均显著下降,而对照组则无此现象。这些结果表明MS患者的周围神经系统存在轻度且进行性的累及。本初步研究中的大多数差异处于统计学意义的临界值,因此我们的假设应在更大样本量的研究中得到证实。