Grossman Z D, Wistow B W, Bryan P J, Dinn W M, McAfee J G, Kieffer S A
J Nucl Med. 1977 Apr;18(4):327-32.
Transmission computed tomography (CT), gray-scale ultrasonography, and scinitillation-camera imaging were compared for detection of intrahepatic space-occupying processes. Fifty patients with suspected liver disease were studied by the three modalities. In the 35 cases with confirmed abnormalities, the madalities were rated on a scale of 0 to 5 in terms of their detection value; Each modality was found to have definite advantages and disadvantages. The mean score of ultrasound was highest (3.61), followed by nuclear medicine (3.11) and then CT (2.77). The combination of ultrasound and nuclear medicine identified all lesions, whereas CT alone or in combination with another technique occasionally failed to detect abnormal foci. In the future, the relative efficacy of these procedures may change with improved imaging technology and increased interpreter experience.
对透射计算机断层扫描(CT)、灰度超声检查和闪烁照相机成像检测肝内占位性病变的情况进行了比较。采用这三种检查方法对50例疑似肝脏疾病的患者进行了研究。在35例确诊有异常的病例中,根据其检测价值将这几种检查方法按0至5分进行评分;发现每种检查方法都有明确的优缺点。超声检查的平均得分最高(3.61分),其次是核医学检查(3.11分),然后是CT(2.77分)。超声和核医学联合检查能发现所有病变,而单独的CT检查或CT与其他技术联合检查偶尔会漏诊异常病灶。未来,随着成像技术的改进和解读人员经验的增加,这些检查方法的相对效能可能会发生变化。