Schonwald Alison, Huntington Noelle, Chan Eugenia, Risko Wanessa, Bridgemohan Carolyn
Divisions of Developmental Medicine, Children's Hospital Boston, 300 Longwood Ave, Boston, MA 02115, USA.
Pediatrics. 2009 Feb;123(2):660-8. doi: 10.1542/peds.2007-2798.
The purpose of this study was to examine the feasibility and effectiveness of implementation of validated developmental screening by using the Parents' Evaluation of Developmental Status in 2 urban pediatric practices.
We implemented the Parents' Evaluation of Developmental Status at Boston Children's Hospital Primary Care Center and at Joseph Smith Community Health Center as quality improvement initiatives. Each practice offered screening to all of the patients attending well-child care visits between 6 months and 8 years of age. The implementation process was investigated by using preimplementation and postimplementation surveys and a focus group of pediatric primary care providers. To assess outcomes, such as changes in identification rates and referrals for developmental and behavioral concerns, we reviewed medical charts of all of the 2- and 3-year-olds present at Children's Hospital Primary Care Center well-child care visits in the periods before and after screening implementation.
Providers found routine screening easier than expected and feasible to conduct in a busy primary care setting. The practice change resulted in screening of 61.6% of eligible children. Compared with same-aged children before screening, after screening was implemented more behavioral concerns were detected in the 2-year-old group, and more children with developmental concerns were identified in the 3-year-old group. Referral rates for additional evaluation increased only for 3-year-olds, although the types of referrals (ie, audiology and early intervention) were consistent as those found before screening started.
Implementation of validated screening by using the Parents' Evaluation of Developmental Status was feasible in large, urban settings. Effectiveness was demonstrated via chart review documenting an increased rate of identification of developmental and behavioral concerns. Perceived obstacles, such as the time requirement, should not prevent widespread adoption of screening.
本研究旨在探讨在两家城市儿科诊所使用《父母发育状况评估量表》实施有效发育筛查的可行性和有效性。
我们在波士顿儿童医院初级保健中心和约瑟夫·史密斯社区健康中心实施了《父母发育状况评估量表》,作为质量改进措施。每家诊所对所有6个月至8岁前来进行健康儿童检查的患者进行筛查。通过实施前和实施后的调查以及儿科初级保健提供者焦点小组对实施过程进行了调查。为了评估结果,例如识别率的变化以及发育和行为问题的转诊情况,我们查阅了儿童医院初级保健中心在筛查实施前后各时间段进行健康儿童检查的所有2岁和3岁儿童的病历。
提供者发现常规筛查比预期更容易,并且在繁忙的初级保健环境中可行。实践变革导致61.6%的符合条件的儿童接受了筛查。与筛查前的同龄儿童相比,实施筛查后,2岁组中检测到更多行为问题,3岁组中识别出更多有发育问题的儿童。仅3岁儿童的进一步评估转诊率有所增加,尽管转诊类型(即听力检查和早期干预)与筛查开始前一致。
在大型城市环境中,使用《父母发育状况评估量表》实施有效筛查是可行的。通过病历审查证明了在识别发育和行为问题方面的有效率有所提高。诸如时间要求等可感知的障碍不应妨碍筛查的广泛采用。