Aylward M, Holly F, Maddock J, Wheeldon R
Curr Med Res Opin. 1976;4(10):695-702. doi: 10.1185/03007997609112004.
A double-blind between-patient trial over 6 weeks to compare the effects of 1.6 g tolmetin daily with 4 g alclofenac daily was completed by 37 out of 44 out-patients with rheumatoid arthritis. Tolmetin proved as effective as alclofenac in relieving pain and in reducing both the articular index score and the number of inflamed joints. However, alclofenac produced a significantly greater reduction in the duration of morning stiffness, which could have been related to the timing of the initial daily dose of tolmetin. Onset of fatigue was significantly improved by both drugs. Neither treatment group exhibited any significant changes in the serum levels of IgG, IgA, and IgM, nor in the latex and sheep-cell agglutination titres. Although neither drug gave rise to serious side-effects, 3 patients (2 on tolmetin, 1 on alclofenac) were withdrawn because of skin rash, 2 (on tolmetin) because of gastro-intestinal upsets, and 1 from each group because of lack of analgesic effects.
44例类风湿性关节炎门诊患者中有37例完成了一项为期6周的双盲患者间试验,比较每日服用1.6克托美丁与每日服用4克阿氯芬酸的效果。托美丁在缓解疼痛以及降低关节指数评分和炎症关节数量方面被证明与阿氯芬酸一样有效。然而,阿氯芬酸在缩短晨僵持续时间方面的降幅明显更大,这可能与托美丁每日初始剂量的服用时间有关。两种药物均能显著改善疲劳的发作情况。两个治疗组的IgG、IgA和IgM血清水平以及乳胶和绵羊细胞凝集滴度均未出现任何显著变化。虽然两种药物均未引起严重的副作用,但有3例患者(2例服用托美丁,1例服用阿氯芬酸)因皮疹退出试验,2例(服用托美丁)因胃肠道不适退出试验,每组各有1例因缺乏镇痛效果退出试验。