Lu Zhenyu, Zhang Yingkai
Department of Chemistry, New York University, New York, 10003.
J Chem Theory Comput. 2008;4(8):1237-48. doi: 10.1021/ct800116e.
In order to further improve the accuracy and applicability of combined quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical (QM/MM) methods, we have interfaced the ab initio QM method with the classical Drude oscillator polarizable MM force field (ai-QM/MM-Drude). Different coupling approaches have been employed and compared: 1. the conventional dual self-consistent-field (SCF) procedure; 2. the direct SCF scheme, in which QM densities and MM Drude positions are converged simultaneously; 3. the micro-iterative SCF scheme, in which the Drude positions of the polarizable model are fully converged during each self-consistent field (SCF) step of QM calculations; 4. the one-step-Drude-update scheme, in which the MM Drude positions are updated only once instead of fully converged during each molecular dynamics (MD) step. The last three coupling approaches are found to be efficient and can achieve the desired convergence in a similar number of QM SCF steps comparing with the corresponding QM method coupled to a non-polarizable force field. The feasibility and applicability of the implemented ai-QM/MM-Drude approach have been demonstrated by carrying out Born-Oppenheimer molecular dynamics simulations with the umbrella sampling method to determine potentials of mean force for both the methyl transfer reaction of the methyl chlorine-chlorine ion system and the glycine intra-molecular proton transfer reaction in aqueous solution. Our results indicate that the ai-QM/MM-Drude approach is very promising, which provides a better description of QM/MM interactions while can achieve quite similar computational efficiency in comparison with the corresponding conventional ab initio QM/MM method.
为了进一步提高量子力学/分子力学(QM/MM)组合方法的准确性和适用性,我们将从头算量子力学方法与经典的德鲁德振子极化分子力学力场(ai-QM/MM-Drude)进行了对接。采用并比较了不同的耦合方法:1. 传统的双自洽场(SCF)程序;2. 直接SCF方案,其中量子力学密度和分子力学德鲁德位置同时收敛;3. 微迭代SCF方案,其中在量子力学计算的每个自洽场(SCF)步骤中,极化模型的德鲁德位置完全收敛;4. 一步德鲁德更新方案,其中分子力学德鲁德位置仅更新一次,而不是在每个分子动力学(MD)步骤中完全收敛。发现后三种耦合方法是有效的,并且与耦合到非极化力场的相应量子力学方法相比,在相似数量的量子力学SCF步骤中可以实现所需的收敛。通过使用伞形采样方法进行玻恩-奥本海默分子动力学模拟,以确定甲基氯-氯离子体系的甲基转移反应和水溶液中甘氨酸分子内质子转移反应的平均力势,证明了所实现的ai-QM/MM-Drude方法的可行性和适用性。我们的结果表明,ai-QM/MM-Drude方法非常有前景,它能更好地描述QM/MM相互作用,同时与相应的传统从头算QM/MM方法相比,可以实现相当相似的计算效率。