Leathard Helen L, Cook Michael J
Health & Social Care, University of Cumbria, UK.
J Adv Nurs. 2009 Jun;65(6):1318-27. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2648.2008.04949.x. Epub 2009 Feb 20.
This paper is a discussion of practical wisdom (phronesis) and spirituality in holistic caring and strategies to facilitate their application in nurse education.
Phronesis, with its inherent spiritual qualities, is an established aspect of the persona of excellent clinical leaders. There is a strong case for recognizing the value of this characteristic in all nurses, and a strategy is required for engendering the development of phronesis during nurse education.
Electronic searches of Google Scholar and CINAHL were conducted for English language publications in the period 1996-2008. Search terms included combinations of phronesis, spirituality, health, education, pharmacology, medicines and medication education, holistic care and spiritual care. Selection of items for inclusion was based on their pertinence to the arguments being developed and their value as leads to earlier material.
The links between the attributes of effective clinical leaders and those required for holistic caring are explicated and related to phronesis, the acquisition of which involves spiritual development. An explanatory account of phronesis and its applicability to nursing leads to an explanation of how its spiritual aspects in particular might be incorporated into learning for holistic care. Reference to research in medicines-related education illustrates how the principles can be applied in nurse education.
Nursing quality could be enhanced if adequate opportunities for acquiring phronesis through experiential learning were provided in nursing curricula. Phronesis and spiritual care could be incorporated into existing models of nursing care or new models devised to use these critical concepts.
本文探讨整体护理中的实践智慧(phronesis)与灵性以及促进其在护理教育中应用的策略。
实践智慧具有内在的精神特质,是优秀临床领导者人格的既定方面。有充分理由认识到这一特质在所有护士身上的价值,并且需要一种策略来促进护理教育过程中实践智慧的发展。
对谷歌学术和CINAHL进行电子检索,查找1996年至2008年期间的英文出版物。检索词包括实践智慧、灵性、健康、教育、药理学、药物与药物教育、整体护理和精神护理的组合。纳入项目的选择基于它们与所阐述论点的相关性以及作为获取早期资料线索的价值。
阐述了有效临床领导者的特质与整体护理所需特质之间的联系,并将其与实践智慧相关联,实践智慧的获得涉及精神发展。对实践智慧及其在护理中的适用性的解释,进而说明了如何将其精神层面,特别是纳入整体护理学习中。引用药物相关教育的研究说明了这些原则如何应用于护理教育。
如果护理课程中提供通过体验式学习获得实践智慧的充足机会,护理质量可能会得到提高。实践智慧和精神护理可以纳入现有的护理模式或为使用这些关键概念而设计的新模式中。