Hirsch Ariel E, Mulleady Bishop Pauline, Dad Luqman, Singh Deeptej, Slanetz Priscilla J
Department of Radiation Oncology, Boston University Medical Center, Boston, MA, USA.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2009 Mar 15;73(4):1003-8; quiz 1008.e1-1008.e2. doi: 10.1016/j.ijrobp.2008.12.012.
The Oncology Education Initiative was created to advance oncology and radiation oncology education by integrating structured didactics into the existing core radiology clerkship. We set out to determine whether the addition of structured didactics could lead to a significant increase in overall medical student knowledge about radiation oncology.
We conducted a pre- and posttest examining concepts in general radiation oncology, breast cancer, and prostate cancer. The 15-question, multiple-choice exam was administered before and after a 1.5-hour didactic lecture by an attending physician in radiation oncology. Individual question changes, overall student changes, and overall categorical changes were analyzed. All hypothesis tests were two-tailed (significance level 0.05).
Of the 153 fourth-year students, 137 (90%) took the pre- and posttest and were present for the didactic lecture. The average test grade improved from 59% to 70% (p = 0.011). Improvement was seen in all questions except clinical vignettes involving correct identification of TNM staging. Statistically significant improvement (p <or= 0.03) was seen in the questions regarding acute and late side effects of radiation, brachytherapy for prostate cancer, delivery of radiation treatment, and management of early-stage breast cancer.
Addition of didactics in radiation oncology significantly improves medical students' knowledge of the topic. Despite perceived difficulty in teaching radiation oncology and the assumption that it is beyond the scope of reasonable knowledge for medical students, we have shown that even with one dedicated lecture, students can learn and absorb general principles regarding radiation oncology.
肿瘤学教育倡议旨在通过将结构化教学融入现有的核心放射学实习课程,推进肿瘤学和放射肿瘤学教育。我们着手确定添加结构化教学是否会显著提高医学生对放射肿瘤学的整体知识水平。
我们进行了一项前后测试,考查一般放射肿瘤学、乳腺癌和前列腺癌的相关概念。在放射肿瘤学主治医师进行1.5小时的教学讲座前后,进行了一场包含15道选择题的考试。分析了单个问题的变化、学生整体的变化以及整体分类的变化。所有假设检验均为双侧检验(显著性水平0.05)。
在153名四年级学生中,137名(90%)参加了前后测试并出席了教学讲座。平均考试成绩从59%提高到了70%(p = 0.011)。除了涉及正确识别TNM分期的临床病例 vignettes 外,所有问题都有改进。在关于放射的急性和晚期副作用、前列腺癌的近距离放射治疗、放射治疗的实施以及早期乳腺癌的管理等问题上,观察到了具有统计学意义的显著改进(p≤0.03)。
在放射肿瘤学中添加教学内容可显著提高医学生对该主题的知识水平。尽管人们认为放射肿瘤学教学存在困难,且认为其超出了医学生合理知识范围的假设,但我们已经表明,即使只有一次专门的讲座,学生也能够学习并吸收放射肿瘤学的一般原则。