King Gillian, Servais Michelle, Kertoy Marilyn, Specht Jacqueline, Currie Melissa, Rosenbaum Peter, Law Mary, Forchuk Cheryl, Chalmers Heather, Willoughby Teena
Child and Parent Resource Institute, 600 Sanatorium Road, London, Ontario, Canada.
Eval Program Plann. 2009 Aug;32(3):289-99. doi: 10.1016/j.evalprogplan.2009.02.002. Epub 2009 Feb 20.
Currently, there are no psychometrically sound outcome measures by which to assess the impacts of research partnerships. This article describes the development of a 33-item, survey questionnaire measuring community members' perceptions of the impact of research partnerships addressing health or social issues. The Community Impacts of Research Oriented Partnerships (CIROP) was developed using information from the literatures on health promotion, community development, research utilization, and community-based participatory research, and from focus groups involving 29 key informants. Data from 174 community members were used to determine the factor structure, internal consistency, and test-retest reliability of the four CIROP scales, and to provide evidence of construct validity. The CIROP informs research partnerships about the extent of their impact in the areas of Personal Knowledge Development, Personal Research Skill Development, Organizational/Group Access To and Use of Information, and Community and Organizational Development, allowing them to demonstrate accountability to funding bodies. As well, the CIROP can be used as a research tool to assess the effectiveness of knowledge sharing approaches, determine the most influential activities of research partnerships, and determine structural characteristics of partnerships associated with various types of impact. The CIROP provides a better understanding of community members' perspectives and expectations of research partnerships, with important implications for knowledge transfer and uptake.
目前,尚无心理测量学上合理的结果指标可用于评估研究伙伴关系的影响。本文描述了一份包含33个条目的调查问卷的编制过程,该问卷用于测量社区成员对针对健康或社会问题的研究伙伴关系影响的看法。“以研究为导向的伙伴关系的社区影响”(CIROP)问卷是利用健康促进、社区发展、研究利用和基于社区的参与性研究等方面的文献资料,以及来自29名关键信息提供者的焦点小组讨论信息编制而成。来自174名社区成员的数据用于确定CIROP四个量表的因子结构、内部一致性和重测信度,并提供结构效度的证据。CIROP能让研究伙伴关系了解其在个人知识发展、个人研究技能发展、组织/团体获取和使用信息以及社区和组织发展等领域的影响程度,使其能够向资助机构证明其责任。此外,CIROP可用作研究工具,以评估知识共享方法的有效性,确定研究伙伴关系中最具影响力的活动,并确定与各种影响类型相关的伙伴关系的结构特征。CIROP有助于更好地理解社区成员对研究伙伴关系的看法和期望,对知识转移和吸收具有重要意义。