Le Blanc M, McDuff P, Tremblay R E
Sante Ment Que. 1991 Jun;16(1):45-75.
Available data on the impact of certain types of families is lacking, and the results are often misleading with respect to maladjustment. Following a description of variations in delinquent activity and behaviour problems according to family type, the authors analyse the difficulties in the operation of family systems. Comparisons of six family types apply to data from 763 boys aged 10, 319 female and 426 male adolescents, aged 14 and 15: intact families, father-based and mother-based single-parent families, father-based and mother-based reconstituted families and substitute families. The article's data show that in the late eighties, nearly 40 per cent of children and adolescents living in low-income districts in Montreal belonged to disunited families. In addition, the data confirm a classic observation: in comparison with intact families, disunited families are underprivileged in relation to living conditions, deficient in relation to psychosocial functioning, and propitious to behaviour problems and delinquent activity. In addition, it has been established that certain disunited family types represent a considerable risk factor. The damaging effect of family structure increases in the following order: intact families, mother-based single-parent families, mother-based reconstituted families, substitute families, father-based reconstituted families and father-based single-parent families. Finally, certain intervention methods are suggested to help prevent behaviour and family problems.
关于某些类型家庭的影响,现有的数据匮乏,而且有关适应不良的研究结果往往具有误导性。在描述了根据家庭类型划分的犯罪活动和行为问题的差异之后,作者分析了家庭系统运作中的困难。对六种家庭类型的比较适用于来自763名10岁男孩、319名14岁和15岁的女性青少年以及426名男性青少年的数据:完整家庭、以父亲为基础的单亲家庭、以母亲为基础的单亲家庭、以父亲为基础的重组家庭、以母亲为基础的重组家庭和替代家庭。文章的数据表明,在八十年代后期,生活在蒙特利尔低收入地区的儿童和青少年中,近40%属于破裂家庭。此外,数据证实了一个经典的观察结果:与完整家庭相比,破裂家庭在生活条件方面处于劣势,在心理社会功能方面存在缺陷,并且容易出现行为问题和犯罪活动。此外,已经确定某些破裂家庭类型是一个相当大的风险因素。家庭结构的破坏作用按以下顺序增加:完整家庭、以母亲为基础的单亲家庭、以母亲为基础的重组家庭、替代家庭、以父亲为基础的重组家庭和以父亲为基础的单亲家庭。最后,文章提出了某些干预方法,以帮助预防行为和家庭问题。