Feinendegen Ludwig E, Pollycove Myron, Sondhaus Charles A
Nuclear Medicine, Heinrich-Heine-University Düsseldorf, Germany; and Medical Department, Brookhaven National Laboratory, Upton, New York.
Nonlinearity Biol Toxicol Med. 2004 Jul;2(3):143-71. doi: 10.1080/15401420490507431.
Biological tissues operate through cells that act together within signaling networks. These assure coordinated cell function in the face of constant exposure to an array of potentially toxic agents, externally from the environment and endogenously from metabolism. Living tissues are indeed complex adaptive systems.To examine tissue effects specific for low-dose radiation, (1) absorbed dose in tissue is replaced by the sum of the energies deposited by each track event, or hit, in a cell-equivalent tissue micromass (1 ng) in all micromasses exposed, that is, by the mean energy delivered by all microdose hits in the exposed micromasses, with cell dose expressing the total energy per micromass from multiple microdoses; and (2) tissue effects are related to cell damage and protective cellular responses per average microdose hit from a given radiation quality for all such hits in the exposed micromasses.The probability of immediate DNA damage per low-linear-energy-transfer (LET) average micro-dose hit is extremely small, increasing over a certain dose range in proportion to the number of hits. Delayed temporary adaptive protection (AP) involves (a) induced detoxification of reactive oxygen species, (b) enhanced rate of DNA repair, (c) induced removal of damaged cells by apoptosis followed by normal cell replacement and by cell differentiation, and (d) stimulated immune response, all with corresponding changes in gene expression. These AP categories may last from less than a day to weeks and be tested by cell responses against renewed irradiation. They operate physiologically against nonradiogenic, largely endogenous DNA damage, which occurs abundantly and continually. Background radiation damage caused by rare microdose hits per micromass is many orders of magnitude less frequent. Except for apoptosis, AP increasingly fails above about 200 mGy of low-LET radiation, corresponding to about 200 microdose hits per exposed micromass. This ratio appears to exceed approximately 1 per day for protracted exposure. The balance between damage and protection favors protection at low cell doses and damage at high cell doses. Bystander effects from high-dosed cells to nonirradiated neighboring cells appear to include both damage and protection.Regarding oncogenesis, a model based on the aforementioned dual response pattern at low doses and dose rates is consistant with the nonlinear reponse data and contradicts the linear no-threshold dose-risk hypothesis for radiation-induced cancer. Indeed, a dose-cancer risk function should include both linear and nonlinear terms.
生物组织通过在信号网络中协同作用的细胞来运作。面对持续暴露于一系列潜在有毒物质(外部来自环境,内部来自新陈代谢)的情况,这些细胞确保了细胞功能的协调。活组织实际上是复杂的自适应系统。为了研究低剂量辐射对组织的特定影响,(1)组织中的吸收剂量被每个径迹事件(即击中)在所有暴露的细胞等效组织微团(1纳克)中沉积的能量总和所取代,也就是说,被暴露微团中所有微剂量击中所传递的平均能量所取代,细胞剂量表示来自多个微剂量的每个微团的总能量;(2)组织效应与暴露微团中给定辐射质量的每个平均微剂量击中所导致的细胞损伤和保护性细胞反应相关。每个低线性能量转移(LET)平均微剂量击中导致即时DNA损伤的概率极小,在一定剂量范围内会随着击中次数的增加而成比例增加。延迟的临时适应性保护(AP)包括:(a)诱导活性氧解毒;(b)提高DNA修复速率;(c)通过凋亡诱导受损细胞清除,随后进行正常细胞替代和细胞分化;(d)刺激免疫反应,所有这些都伴随着基因表达的相应变化。这些AP类别可能持续不到一天到数周,并可通过细胞对再次照射的反应来测试。它们在生理上对抗非辐射性的、主要是内源性的DNA损伤,这种损伤大量且持续发生。每个微团中罕见微剂量击中引起的背景辐射损伤频率要低很多个数量级。除了凋亡,在低LET辐射约200毫戈瑞以上时,AP越来越失效,这相当于每个暴露微团约有2个微剂量击中。对于长期暴露,这个比例似乎每天超过约1次。损伤与保护之间的平衡在低细胞剂量时有利于保护,在高细胞剂量时有利于损伤。高剂量细胞对未受照射的邻近细胞的旁观者效应似乎包括损伤和保护。关于肿瘤发生,基于上述低剂量和低剂量率下的双重反应模式的模型与非线性反应数据一致,并且与辐射诱发癌症的线性无阈剂量风险假设相矛盾。实际上,剂量 - 癌症风险函数应该包括线性和非线性项。