Treur M J, McCracken F, Heeg B, Joshi A V, Botteman M F, De Charro F, Van Hout B
Pharmerit BV, AV Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Haemophilia. 2009 Mar;15(2):420-36. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2516.2008.01956.x.
The optimal on-demand treatment of joint bleeds in haemophilia patients with inhibitors is a source of debate, with studies reporting various efficacy levels for different drugs and dosage regimens. To analyse, in a unified Bayesian meta-regression model, the published efficacy of recombinant activated factor VII (rFVIIa) and/or activated prothrombin complex concentrate (aPCC) as on-demand treatments for joint bleeds in haemophilia patients with inhibitors. A systematic search was carried out to identify studies reporting on dosage and efficacy of rFVIIa and aPCC in the treatment of joint bleeds in the target patient population. Data were abstracted and included in the model and adjusted for potential sources of heterogeneity. Pooled efficacy levels for typical rFVIIa and aPCC regimens were estimated. Seventeen studies, collectively reporting on >2000 joint bleeds, were included. Medication type combined with dosage was the only significant explanatory parameter. The model predicts that a typical regimen of 90 microg kg(-1) rFVII repeated every 3 h if needed results in cumulative joint bleed resolution of 66%, 88% and 95% after 12, 24 and 36 h, respectively. In comparison, a typical regimen of 75 IU kg(-1) aPCC repeated every 12 h if needed results in cumulative joint bleed resolution of 39%, 62% and 76%, respectively. These differences were statistically significant and were also robust in sensitivity analyses. This analysis suggests that a typical rFVIIa regimen will resolve joint bleeds more effectively than a typical aPCC regimen after 12, 24 and 36 h.
对于有抑制物的血友病患者关节出血的最佳按需治疗存在争议,不同研究报道了不同药物和给药方案的各种疗效水平。在统一的贝叶斯元回归模型中分析重组活化凝血因子VII(rFVIIa)和/或活化凝血酶原复合物浓缩物(aPCC)作为有抑制物的血友病患者关节出血按需治疗的已发表疗效。进行系统检索以识别报告rFVIIa和aPCC在目标患者群体关节出血治疗中的剂量和疗效的研究。提取数据并纳入模型,并针对潜在的异质性来源进行调整。估计了典型rFVIIa和aPCC方案的合并疗效水平。纳入了17项研究,共报告了>2000例关节出血。药物类型与剂量相结合是唯一显著的解释参数。该模型预测,如果需要,每3小时重复一次90μg kg(-1) rFVII的典型方案,在12、24和36小时后累积关节出血缓解率分别为66%、88%和95%。相比之下,如果需要,每12小时重复一次75 IU kg(-1) aPCC的典型方案,累积关节出血缓解率分别为39%、62%和76%。这些差异具有统计学意义,并且在敏感性分析中也很稳健。该分析表明,在12、24和36小时后,典型的rFVIIa方案比典型的aPCC方案更有效地缓解关节出血。