Jakobs Oliver, Wang Ling E, Dafotakis Manuel, Grefkes Christian, Zilles Karl, Eickhoff Simon B
C. and O. Vogt Institute for Brain Research, Heinrich-Heine-University Düsseldorf, Germany.
Neuroimage. 2009 Aug 15;47(2):667-77. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2009.04.065. Epub 2009 May 3.
The concept of predictive coding supposes the brain to build predictions of forthcoming events in order to decrease the computational load, thereby facilitating efficient reactions. In contrast, increasing uncertainty, i.e., lower predictability, should increase reaction time and neural activity due to reactive processing and believe updating. We used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to scan subjects reacting to briefly presented arrows pointing to either side by pressing a button with the corresponding index finger. Predictability of these stimuli was manipulated along the independently varied factors "response type" (known hand or random, i.e., unknown order) and "timing" (fixed or variable intervals between stimuli). Behavioural data showed a significant reaction-time advantage when either factor was predictable, confirming the hypothesised reduction in computational load. On the neural level, only the right temporo-parietal junction showed enhanced activation upon both increased task and timing uncertainty. Moreover, activity in this region also positively correlated with reaction time. There was, however, a dissociation between both factors in the frontal lobe, as increased timing uncertainty recruited right BA 44, whereas increased response uncertainty activated the right ventral premotor cortex, the pre-SMA and the DLPFC. In line with the theoretical framework of predictive coding as a load-saving mechanism no brain region showed significantly increased activity in the lower uncertainty conditions or correlated negatively with reaction times. This study hence provided behavioural and neuroimaging evidence for predictive motor coding and points to a key role of the right temporo-parietal junction in its implementation.
预测编码的概念假定大脑会对即将发生的事件进行预测,以减少计算负荷,从而促进高效反应。相反,不确定性增加,即可预测性降低,由于反应性处理和信念更新,应会增加反应时间和神经活动。我们使用功能磁共振成像(fMRI)扫描受试者,让他们通过用相应的食指按按钮来对短暂呈现的指向两侧的箭头做出反应。这些刺激的可预测性是沿着独立变化的因素“反应类型”(已知手或随机,即未知顺序)和“时间”(刺激之间的固定或可变间隔)来操纵的。行为数据显示,当任何一个因素可预测时,都有显著的反应时间优势,证实了计算负荷降低的假设。在神经层面,只有右侧颞顶叶交界处的激活在任务和时间不确定性增加时增强。此外,该区域的活动也与反应时间呈正相关。然而,在额叶中这两个因素之间存在分离,因为时间不确定性增加会激活右侧BA 44,而反应不确定性增加会激活右侧腹侧运动前皮质、前辅助运动区和背外侧前额叶皮质。与预测编码作为一种负荷节省机制的理论框架一致,在较低不确定性条件下,没有脑区显示出显著增加的活动,也没有与反应时间呈负相关。因此,本研究为预测性运动编码提供了行为和神经影像学证据,并指出右侧颞顶叶交界处在其实施中的关键作用。