Norris Fran H, Tracy Melissa, Galea Sandro
Dartmouth Medical School, Psychiatry/NCPTSD, VA Medical Center, White River Junction, VT 05009, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2009 Jun;68(12):2190-8. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2009.03.043. Epub 2009 May 4.
Taking advantage of two large, population-based, and longitudinal datasets collected after the 1999 floods in Mexico (n=561) and the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks in New York (n=1267), we examined the notion that resilience may be best understood and measured as one member of a set of trajectories that may follow exposure to trauma or severe stress. We hypothesized that resistance, resilience, recovery, relapsing/remitting, delayed dysfunction, and chronic dysfunction trajectories were all possible in the aftermath of major disasters. Semi-parametric group-based modeling yielded the strongest evidence for resistance (no or mild and stable symptoms), resilience (initially moderate or severe symptoms followed by a sharp decrease), recovery (initially moderate or severe symptoms followed by a gradual decrease), and chronic dysfunction (moderate or severe and stable symptoms), as these trajectories were prevalent in both samples. Neither Mexico nor New York showed a relapsing/remitting trajectory, and only New York showed a delayed dysfunction trajectory. Understanding patterns of psychological distress over time may present opportunities for interventions that aim to increase resilience, and decrease more adverse trajectories, after mass traumatic events.
利用墨西哥1999年洪灾(n = 561)和2001年9月11日纽约恐怖袭击事件后收集的两个大型、基于人群的纵向数据集,我们研究了这样一种观点,即复原力可能最好被理解和衡量为一组轨迹中的一个成员,这些轨迹可能在遭受创伤或严重压力后出现。我们假设,在重大灾难之后,抵抗、复原力、恢复、复发/缓解、延迟功能障碍和慢性功能障碍轨迹都是可能的。基于半参数分组的建模为抵抗(无或轻微且稳定的症状)、复原力(最初为中度或重度症状,随后急剧下降)、恢复(最初为中度或重度症状,随后逐渐下降)和慢性功能障碍(中度或重度且稳定的症状)提供了最有力的证据,因为这些轨迹在两个样本中都很普遍。墨西哥和纽约都没有出现复发/缓解轨迹,只有纽约出现了延迟功能障碍轨迹。了解心理困扰随时间的模式可能为旨在在大规模创伤事件后提高复原力和减少更不利轨迹的干预措施提供机会。