Thompson Lindsay A, Knapp Caprice, Madden Vanessa, Shenkman Elizabeth
Department of Pediatrics, College of Medicine, University of Florida, 1701 SW 16th Ave, Room 2103, Gainesville, FL 32608, USA.
Pediatrics. 2009 May;123(5):e777-82. doi: 10.1542/peds.2008-2721.
This study investigates how pediatricians define palliative care and their preferences regarding the timing of referrals for children with life-limiting diseases.
A random sample of 800 pediatricians in Florida and California received mail and online surveys. Analyses included descriptive and multivariate regression analyses.
Of all respondents (N = 303), 49.1% were female, 34.0% had been practicing for > or =20 years, 44.2% were members of a racial/ethnic minority, and 76.2% were in private practice. Pediatricians were divided in their definitions of palliative care; 41.9% defined it as hospice care, 31.9% offered alternative definitions, and 26.2% did not know. Although pediatricians overwhelmingly cited the need for many types of palliative care services, only 49.3% had ever referred patients to palliative care and 29.4% did not know whether local services existed. For 13 diseases that vary in life limitation, there was no consensus regarding the timing of referrals. Diversity across diseases predicted the most variation in referrals, whereas pediatrician characteristics did not.
Despite recommendations to refer children to palliative care early in the course of illness, most pediatricians define palliative care as similar to hospice care and refer patients once curative therapy is no longer an option. Creating a more-practical definition of care, one that emphasizes an array of services throughout the course of an illness, as opposed to hospice care, may increase earlier palliative care referrals for children with life-limiting illnesses.
本研究调查儿科医生如何定义姑息治疗以及他们对患有危及生命疾病儿童的转诊时机的偏好。
对佛罗里达州和加利福尼亚州的800名儿科医生进行随机抽样,通过邮件和在线方式进行调查。分析包括描述性分析和多变量回归分析。
在所有受访者(N = 303)中,49.1%为女性,34.0%从业时间≥20年,44.2%属于少数种族/族裔,76.2%从事私人执业。儿科医生对姑息治疗的定义存在分歧;41.9%将其定义为临终关怀,31.9%给出了其他定义,26.2%表示不知道。尽管儿科医生绝大多数都提到需要多种类型的姑息治疗服务,但只有49.3%曾将患者转诊至姑息治疗,29.4%不知道当地是否有此类服务。对于13种生命受限程度不同的疾病,在转诊时机上没有达成共识。疾病之间的差异对转诊差异的预测作用最大,而儿科医生的特征并非如此。
尽管有建议在疾病早期就将儿童转诊至姑息治疗,但大多数儿科医生将姑息治疗定义为类似于临终关怀,并在治愈性治疗不再是选项时才转诊患者。制定一个更实用的护理定义,强调在疾病全过程提供一系列服务,而非临终关怀,可能会增加对患有危及生命疾病儿童的早期姑息治疗转诊。