Leigh R J, Burnstine T H, Ruff R L, Kasmer R J
Department of Neurology, University Hospitals, Cleveland, OH 44106.
Neurology. 1991 Nov;41(11):1737-41. doi: 10.1212/wnl.41.11.1737.
We conducted a randomized, double-blind, crossover trial of two anticholinergic agents--trihexyphenidyl and tridihexethyl chloride (a quaternary anticholinergic that does not cross the blood-brain barrier)--in patients with acquired nystagmus and measured visual acuity and nystagmus before and at the end of 1 month on each medication. Of the 10 patients admitted to the study, only five completed trials of both drugs due to intolerance of medication or intercurrent illness. Of six patients who completed the trial of trihexyphenidyl, only one showed improvement. Of six patients who completed a trial of tridihexethyl chloride, four showed improvement. We conclude that (1) trihexyphenidyl is not a reliable treatment for acquired nystagmus, although occasional patients may benefit; (2) anticholinergic agents may suppress nystagmus by peripheral rather than central mechanisms; and (3) the side effects of anticholinergic agents limit their effectiveness in the treatment of nystagmus.
我们对10例获得性眼球震颤患者进行了一项随机、双盲、交叉试验,比较了两种抗胆碱能药物——苯海索和氯氮卓(一种不透过血脑屏障的季铵类抗胆碱能药物),并在每种药物治疗前及治疗1个月结束时测量了视力和眼球震颤情况。在纳入研究的10例患者中,仅有5例因药物不耐受或并发疾病完成了两种药物的试验。在完成苯海索试验的6例患者中,只有1例有所改善。在完成氯氮卓试验的6例患者中,有4例有所改善。我们得出结论:(1)苯海索对获得性眼球震颤并非可靠的治疗方法,尽管偶尔有患者可能受益;(2)抗胆碱能药物可能通过外周而非中枢机制抑制眼球震颤;(3)抗胆碱能药物的副作用限制了其在治疗眼球震颤方面的有效性。