Gu Li-sha, Kim Jong Ryul, Ling Junqi, Choi Kyung Kyu, Pashley David H, Tay Franklin R
Department of Operative Dentistry and Endodontics, Guanghua School of Stomatology, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou, China.
J Endod. 2009 Jun;35(6):791-804. doi: 10.1016/j.joen.2009.03.010.
Effective irrigant delivery and agitation are prerequisites for successful endodontic treatment.
This article presents an overview of the irrigant agitation methods currently available and their debridement efficacy.
Technological advances during the last decade have brought to fruition new agitation devices that rely on various mechanisms of irrigant transfer, soft tissue debridement, and, depending on treatment philosophy, removal of smear layers. These devices might be divided into the manual and machine-assisted agitation systems. Overall, they appear to have resulted in improved canal cleanliness when compared with conventional syringe needle irrigation. Despite the plethora of in vitro studies, no well-controlled study is available. This raises imperative concerns on the need for studies that could more effectively evaluate specific irrigation methods by using standardized debris or biofilm models. In addition, no evidence-based study is available to date that attempts to correlate the clinical efficacy of these devices with improved treatment outcomes. Thus, the question of whether these devices are really necessary remains unresolved. There also appears to be the need to refocus from a practice management perspective on how these devices are perceived by clinicians in terms of their practicality and ease of use.
Understanding these fundamental issues is crucial for clinical scientists to improve the design and user-friendliness of future generations of irrigant agitation systems and for manufacturers' contentions that these systems play a pivotal role in contemporary endodontics.
有效的冲洗液输送和搅动是成功进行牙髓治疗的前提条件。
本文概述了目前可用的冲洗液搅动方法及其清创效果。
过去十年的技术进步使新型搅动装置得以实现,这些装置依靠冲洗液转移、软组织清创以及根据治疗理念去除玷污层的各种机制。这些装置可分为手动和机器辅助搅动系统。总体而言,与传统注射器针头冲洗相比,它们似乎能提高根管清洁度。尽管有大量的体外研究,但尚无严格对照的研究。这引发了迫切关注,即需要开展能通过使用标准化碎屑或生物膜模型更有效评估特定冲洗方法的研究。此外,迄今为止,尚无基于证据的研究试图将这些装置的临床疗效与改善的治疗结果相关联。因此,这些装置是否真的必要这一问题仍未得到解决。从实践管理角度来看,似乎也需要重新关注临床医生如何看待这些装置的实用性和易用性。
理解这些基本问题对于临床科学家改进下一代冲洗液搅动系统的设计和用户友好性以及对于制造商认为这些系统在当代牙髓病学中起关键作用的观点至关重要。