Vaca-Marín M A, Rodríguez-López M H, Bown D N, Ríos R
Departamento de Estudios de Campo, Centro de Investigación de Paludismo, México.
Salud Publica Mex. 1991 Sep-Oct;33(5):482-92.
The effectiveness of low volume (LV) house-spraying of deltamethrin 0.027 per cent and malathion 20 per cent in the control of Anopheles sp was evaluated in two villages of Tabasco, México during the last semester of 1987. Two spray rounds were carried out at three-month intervals, using Fontan R-12 back-pack-space sprayers. Residual effect and cost-benefit were evaluated and compared to the standard DDT spraying technique using the Hudson X-pert sprayer. The entomological evaluation focused on mortality rates and density levels observed from intra and peridomicilliary man biting collections, indoor mosquito resting densities, curtain trap and the standard WHO wall bioassay. It was determined that when using the LV method these insecticides were highly effective. Malathion showed a residual effect of eight weeks whereas deltamethrin was found to have a residual activity of up to 12 weeks. Deltamethrin was more effective in reducing intra and peridomiciliary biting rates, and indoor resting mosquitoes. The cost-benefit ratio of deltamethrin and malathion LV house-spraying was 2.56 and 0.89, respectively, as compared to the standard DDT house-spraying. Considering its effectiveness in anopheline control and its cost-benefit, in addition to being a functional technique, intradomicile LV insecticide spraying should be considered as a practical alternative in malaria control programs.
1987年下半年,在墨西哥塔巴斯科州的两个村庄评估了用0.027%溴氰菊酯和20%马拉硫磷进行低容量(LV)室内喷洒对按蚊的防治效果。每隔三个月进行两轮喷洒,使用丰坦R - 12背负式空间喷雾器。评估了残留效果和成本效益,并与使用哈德逊X - pert喷雾器的标准滴滴涕喷洒技术进行了比较。昆虫学评估集中在室内和室外人叮咬采集观察到的死亡率和密度水平、室内蚊子栖息密度、窗帘诱捕以及标准的世卫组织壁面生物测定。结果确定,使用低容量方法时,这些杀虫剂非常有效。马拉硫磷显示出八周的残留效果,而溴氰菊酯的残留活性高达12周。溴氰菊酯在降低室内和室外叮咬率以及室内栖息蚊子方面更有效。与标准滴滴涕室内喷洒相比,溴氰菊酯和马拉硫磷低容量室内喷洒的成本效益比分别为2.56和0.89。考虑到其在按蚊防治中的有效性及其成本效益,除了是一种实用技术外,室内低容量杀虫剂喷洒应被视为疟疾控制项目中的一种切实可行的替代方法。