Department of Environmental Engineering Sciences, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL 32611-6450, USA.
J Appl Microbiol. 2009 Dec 1;107(6):1912-23. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2672.2009.04375.x. Epub 2009 May 12.
To investigate the performance of an iodine-releasing filter medium for use as a protective device against airborne pathogens.
The filter's physical and viable removal efficiencies (VRE) were investigated with challenges of MS2 bacteriophage aerosols, and the infectivity of MS2 collected on the filter was analysed. To test a proposed inactivation mechanism, media containing thiosulfate or bovine serum albumin (BSA) were put in impingers to quench and consume I(2) released from the filter. In direct plating experiments, treated filters presented significantly higher VREs than did untreated filters; however, collection in excess BSA decreased VRE by half and in thiosulfate the apparent VRE decreased drastically. No significant difference in infectivity of retained viruses on treated and untreated filters was observed at the same environmental condition.
Evidence presented herein for competition by dissolved I(2) in infectivity assays supports a mechanism of induced displacement and capture of I(2.) It also requires that dissociation of iodine from the filter and capture of iodine by MS2 aerosols as they pass through the filter be factored in the design of the assessment methodology. The filter's strong retention capability minimizes reaerosolization but also makes it difficult to discriminate the antimicrobial effect at the surface.
This study shows the direct plating assay method to be sensitive to interference by iodine-releasing materials. This requires reevaluation of earlier reports of VRE measurements.
研究一种释放碘的过滤介质作为防止空气传播病原体的保护装置的性能。
用 MS2 噬菌体气溶胶进行挑战,研究了过滤器的物理和有效去除效率(VRE),并分析了收集在过滤器上的 MS2 的感染性。为了测试一种拟议的失活动力学机制,将含有硫代硫酸盐或牛血清白蛋白(BSA)的介质放入冲击瓶中,以淬灭和消耗从过滤器中释放的 I2。在直接平板实验中,处理过的过滤器的 VRE 明显高于未处理的过滤器;然而,在过量 BSA 中的收集使 VRE 降低了一半,而在硫代硫酸盐中,VRE 明显急剧降低。在相同的环境条件下,处理过的和未处理的过滤器上截留的病毒的感染性没有观察到显著差异。
本文提供的关于溶解 I2 在感染性测定中竞争的证据支持诱导置换和捕获 I2 的机制。这也要求在评估方法的设计中考虑到碘从过滤器上解离以及碘被通过过滤器的 MS2 气溶胶捕获。过滤器的强保留能力最大限度地减少了再气溶胶化,但也使得难以区分表面的抗菌效果。
本研究表明,直接平板测定方法对释放碘的材料的干扰敏感。这需要重新评估早期报道的 VRE 测量结果。