Small P, Barrett D
SMBD-Jewish General Hospital, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Ann Allergy. 1991 Nov;67(5):520-4.
Patients with ragweed-induced seasonal allergic rhinitis were assigned randomly to be challenged intranasally either with ragweed or histamine while asymptomatic before the ragweed season. After initial challenge, all were treated either by placebo (P), beclomethasone dipropionate (BE), 400 micrograms daily, or budesonide (BU), 1200 micrograms daily, intranasally for 14 days. Repeat challenge was then compared with the previous ones in order to assess the effects of both usual (400 micrograms) and high doses (1200 micrograms) of topical steroids on both allergen-induced and nonspecific (histamine) nasal reactivity. Incremental doses of either histamine or ragweed were insufflated intranasally until a positive response defined the threshold reactivity. Reactions were assessed by a combination of changes in flow rates (rhinomanometry), secretions (mL), and sneezes with ten minutes of challenge. There was no difference in initial threshold reactivities among the treatment groups. Neither BE nor BU changed reactivity to ragweed. There were no adverse reactions except epistaxis in two BU patients. Histamine challenges disclosed a change in threshold reactivity, BU (P much less than .01) greater than BE (P much less than .05), compared with placebo. In summary, even high doses (1200 micrograms) of topical steroids had minimal effects on the early response to intranasal ragweed challenge. In contrast, both usual and high doses affected nonspecific histamine reactivity; this may contribute to some of the clinical improvement noted in symptoms of allergic rhinitis.
患有豚草引起的季节性变应性鼻炎的患者在豚草季节前无症状时被随机分配经鼻内给予豚草或组胺进行激发试验。初始激发试验后,所有患者均经鼻内给予安慰剂(P)、二丙酸倍氯米松(BE)每日400微克或布地奈德(BU)每日1200微克治疗14天。然后将重复激发试验与之前的试验进行比较,以评估常规剂量(400微克)和高剂量(1200微克)的局部类固醇对变应原诱导的和非特异性(组胺)鼻反应性的影响。鼻内吹入递增剂量的组胺或豚草,直至阳性反应确定阈值反应性。通过流速变化(鼻阻力测量法)、分泌物量(毫升)和激发试验10分钟内的喷嚏次数综合评估反应。各治疗组初始阈值反应性无差异。BE和BU均未改变对豚草的反应性。除两名使用BU的患者出现鼻出血外,无不良反应。与安慰剂相比,组胺激发试验显示阈值反应性有变化,BU(P远小于0.01)大于BE(P远小于0.05)。总之,即使是高剂量(1200微克)的局部类固醇对鼻内豚草激发试验的早期反应影响也很小。相比之下,常规剂量和高剂量均影响非特异性组胺反应性;这可能有助于变应性鼻炎症状中观察到的一些临床改善。