Clift Robert J W, Rajlic Gordana, Gretton Heather M
Youth Forensic Psychiatric Services, Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada.
Sex Abuse. 2009 Sep;21(3):335-62. doi: 10.1177/1079063209338491. Epub 2009 Jul 8.
The current study addresses the discriminative and predictive validity of the penile plethysmograph (PPG) in a sample of 132 male adolescent sex offenders who were admitted to a sex offender treatment program. The subjects were assessed pretreatment and posttreatment, under two different instructions sets: an Arouse condition, where subjects allowed themselves to become aroused; and a Suppress condition, where subjects attempted to suppress or control their arousal. Under the pretreatment Arouse condition, the group with male child victims demonstrated significantly greater arousal to child stimuli than the group with female nonchild victims. However, the group with female child victims could not be differentiated from the group with female nonchild victims. Under the Suppress condition, there was no evidence of discriminative validity for any of the PPG indices. As for predictive validity, posttreatment arousal to male and female children was significantly related to sexual offense recidivism. Posttreatment inability to suppress deviant arousal to male and female children was also significantly related to sexual offense recidivism over the 6-year follow-up period. In light of these findings, the implications for adolescent sex offender research and treatment are discussed.
本研究探讨了阴茎体积描记法(PPG)在132名被送入性犯罪者治疗项目的男性青少年性犯罪者样本中的区分效度和预测效度。在两种不同的指导条件下,对受试者进行治疗前和治疗后的评估:一种是唤起条件,即受试者让自己被唤起;另一种是抑制条件,即受试者试图抑制或控制自己的唤起。在治疗前的唤起条件下,有男性儿童受害者的组对儿童刺激的唤起明显高于有女性非儿童受害者的组。然而,有女性儿童受害者的组与有女性非儿童受害者的组无法区分。在抑制条件下,没有证据表明任何PPG指标具有区分效度。至于预测效度,治疗后对男性和女性儿童的唤起与性犯罪再犯显著相关。在6年的随访期内,治疗后无法抑制对男性和女性儿童的异常唤起也与性犯罪再犯显著相关。鉴于这些发现,讨论了对青少年性犯罪者研究和治疗的启示。