Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Ain Shams University, Cairo, Egypt.
HSS J. 2009 Sep;5(2):123-8. doi: 10.1007/s11420-009-9125-8. Epub 2009 Jul 10.
Giant cell tumors are neoplasms of mesenchymal stromal cells with varied manifestations. There is no uniform accepted treatment protocol for these tumors. Curettage, although an accepted method of treatment, carries a high local recurrence rate. Adjuvant therapies including high-speed burr debridement, cryotherapy, and phenol treatment have been advocated to reduce local recurrence. We have used these adjuvants to determine if improved cure rate with improved outcomes could be attained with regard to local tumor control and functional outcome. Twenty-eight cases of proven giant cell tumors of the distal femur and proximal tibia were included in this prospective case series. The lesions were at the upper tibia in 14 cases and the lower femur in 14 patients. The patients were evaluated clinically, radiologically, and by histological examination. Companacci grading and Enneking staging were determined. The treatment was done in the following steps: Curettage and further debridement with a high-speed burr, cryotherapy, impaction of the cavity with subchondral iliac crest bone graft, and, finally, cementation with or without internal fixation. Functional evaluation was done by Enneking's system. The follow-up time was between 24-40 months with a mean of 34 months. The functional results of the procedure were rated as good to excellent with a mean of 93.9%. This technique has the advantages of joint preservation, excellent functional outcome, and low recurrence rate when compared with other treatment modalities. For these reasons, it is recommended as an adjuvant to curettage for most giant cell tumors of bone.
巨细胞瘤是一种间充质基质细胞的肿瘤,表现多样。目前对于这类肿瘤并没有统一的治疗方案。刮除术虽然是一种被接受的治疗方法,但局部复发率较高。为了降低局部复发率,已经提倡使用高速钻头清创、冷冻疗法和苯酚处理等辅助疗法。我们使用这些辅助方法来确定是否可以通过改善局部肿瘤控制和功能结果来提高治愈率和改善预后。本前瞻性病例系列研究共纳入 28 例经证实的股骨远端和胫骨近端巨细胞瘤患者。14 例患者病变位于胫骨上段,14 例患者病变位于股骨下段。对患者进行了临床、影像学和组织学检查评估。同时还进行了Companacci 分级和 Enneking 分期评估。治疗步骤如下:刮除术和高速钻头进一步清创、冷冻疗法、用髂嵴骨软骨下骨粒填充空腔、最后用或不用内固定进行骨水泥填充。采用 Enneking 系统进行功能评估。随访时间为 24-40 个月,平均为 34 个月。该方法的功能结果评价为优至良,平均为 93.9%。与其他治疗方法相比,该技术具有保留关节、良好的功能结果和低复发率的优点。因此,建议将其作为刮除术的辅助治疗方法,用于大多数骨巨细胞瘤。