Kosowska-Shick Klaudia, Clark Catherine, Pankuch Glenn A, McGhee Pamela, Dewasse Bonifacio, Beachel Linda, Appelbaum Peter C
Department of Pathology, Hershey Medical Center, Hershey, PA 17033, USA.
Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 2009 Oct;53(10):4217-24. doi: 10.1128/AAC.00742-09. Epub 2009 Jul 20.
This study used CLSI broth microdilution to test the activity of telavancin and comparator antimicrobial agents against 67 methicillin (meticillin)-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) isolates. Twenty-six vancomycin-intermediate S. aureus (VISA) strains were among the isolates tested; all strains were susceptible to telavancin at < or = 1 microg/ml, whereas 12/26 (46%) of these isolates were nonsusceptible to daptomycin at the same concentration. All strains were susceptible to quinupristin-dalfopristin, while resistance was found to all other drugs tested. Telavancin demonstrated potent activity against all vancomycin-susceptible isolates as well as against heterogeneously VISA and VISA resistance phenotypes. In multistep resistance selection studies, telavancin yielded one stable mutant after 43 days in one MRSA strain out of the 10 MRSA strains tested with the MIC rising eightfold from 0.25 microg/ml (parent) to 2 microg/ml. MICs for this clone did not increase further when passages were continued for the maximum 50 days. In contrast, daptomycin selected stable resistant clones (MIC increase of >4x) after 14 to 35 days in 4 of 10 MRSA strains with MICs increasing from 1 to 2 microg/ml (parents) to 4 to 8 microg/ml (resistant clones). Sequencing analysis of daptomycin resistance determinants revealed point mutations in the mprF genes of all four stable daptomycin-resistant clones. Teicoplanin gave rise to resistant clones after 14 to 21 days in 2 of 10 MRSA strains with MICs rising from 1 to 2 microg/ml (parents) to 4 to 16 microg/ml (stable resistant clones). Linezolid selected stable resistant clones after 22 to 48 days in 2 of 10 MRSA strains with MICs rising from 2 to 4 microg/ml (parents) to 32 microg/ml (resistant clones). Vancomycin yielded no resistant clones in 10 MRSA strains tested; however, MICs increased two- to fourfold from 1 to 8 microg/ml to 2 to 16 microg/ml after 50 days. No cross-resistance was found with any clone/antimicrobial combination. The two enterococci developed resistance to daptomycin, and one developed resistance to linezolid. Single-step mutation frequencies for telavancin (<4.0 x 10(-11) to <2.9 x 10(-10) at 2x MIC) were lower than the spontaneous mutation frequencies obtained with the comparators.
本研究采用美国临床和实验室标准协会(CLSI)肉汤微量稀释法,检测替考拉宁和对照抗菌药物对67株耐甲氧西林金黄色葡萄球菌(MRSA)的活性。受试菌株中有26株万古霉素中介金黄色葡萄球菌(VISA);所有菌株对替考拉宁在≤1微克/毫升时均敏感,而这些菌株中有12/26(46%)在相同浓度下对达托霉素不敏感。所有菌株对奎奴普丁-达福普汀均敏感,而对其他所有受试药物均有耐药性。替考拉宁对所有万古霉素敏感菌株以及异质性VISA和VISA耐药表型均表现出强大活性。在多步耐药选择研究中,在测试的10株MRSA菌株中,有1株MRSA菌株在43天后经替考拉宁诱导产生了1个稳定突变体,其最低抑菌浓度(MIC)从0.25微克/毫升(亲本)升至2微克/毫升,升高了8倍。当继续传代最多50天时,该克隆的MIC未进一步增加。相比之下,达托霉素在10株MRSA菌株中的4株中,于14至35天后诱导产生了稳定的耐药克隆(MIC增加>4倍),MIC从1微克/毫升(亲本)升至2微克/毫升(亲本),再升至4至8微克/毫升(耐药克隆)。对达托霉素耐药决定因素的测序分析显示,所有4个稳定的达托霉素耐药克隆的mprF基因均存在点突变。替考拉宁在10株MRSA菌株中的2株中,于14至21天后诱导产生了耐药克隆,MIC从1微克/毫升(亲本)升至2微克/毫升(亲本),再升至4至16微克/毫升(稳定耐药克隆)。利奈唑胺在10株MRSA菌株中的2株中,于22至48天后诱导产生了稳定的耐药克隆,MIC从2微克/毫升(亲本)升至4微克/毫升(亲本),再升至32微克/毫升(耐药克隆)。在测试的10株MRSA菌株中,万古霉素未诱导产生耐药克隆;然而,50天后MIC从1至8微克/毫升增至2至16微克/毫升,增加了2至4倍。未发现任何克隆/抗菌药物组合存在交叉耐药性。两种肠球菌对达托霉素产生了耐药性,一种对利奈唑胺产生了耐药性。替考拉宁的单步突变频率(在2倍MIC时<4.0×10⁻¹¹至<2.9×10⁻¹⁰)低于对照药物的自发突变频率。