Echner G G, Kilby W, Lee M, Earnst E, Sayeh S, Schlaefer A, Rhein B, Dooley J R, Lang C, Blanck O, Lessard E, Maurer C R, Schlegel W
Department of Medical Physics, DKFZ, Im Neuenheimer Feld 280, Heidelberg D-69120, Germany.
Phys Med Biol. 2009 Sep 21;54(18):5359-80. doi: 10.1088/0031-9155/54/18/001. Epub 2009 Aug 18.
Robotic radiosurgery using more than one circular collimator can improve treatment plan quality and reduce total monitor units (MU). The rationale for an iris collimator that allows the field size to be varied during treatment delivery is to enable the benefits of multiple-field-size treatments to be realized with no increase in treatment time due to collimator exchange or multiple traversals of the robotic manipulator by allowing each beam to be delivered with any desired field size during a single traversal. This paper describes the Iris variable aperture collimator (Accuray Incorporated, Sunnyvale, CA, USA), which incorporates 12 tungsten-copper alloy segments in two banks of six. The banks are rotated by 30 degrees with respect to each other, which limits the radiation leakage between the collimator segments and produces a 12-sided polygonal treatment beam. The beam is approximately circular, with a root-mean-square (rms) deviation in the 50% dose radius of <0.8% (corresponding to <0.25 mm at the 60 mm field size) and an rms variation in the 20-80% penumbra width of about 0.1 mm at the 5 mm field size increasing to about 0.5 mm at 60 mm. The maximum measured collimator leakage dose rate was 0.07%. A commissioning method is described by which the average dose profile can be obtained from four profile measurements at each depth based on the periodicity of the isodose line variations with azimuthal angle. The penumbra of averaged profiles increased with field size and was typically 0.2-0.6 mm larger than that of an equivalent fixed circular collimator. The aperture reproducibility is < or =0.1 mm at the lower bank, diverging to < or =0.2 mm at a nominal treatment distance of 800 mm from the beam focus. Output factors (OFs) and tissue-phantom-ratio data are identical to those used for fixed collimators, except the OFs for the two smallest field sizes (5 and 7.5 mm) are considerably lower for the Iris Collimator. If average collimator profiles are used, the assumption of circular symmetry results in dose calculation errors that are <1 mm or <1% for single beams across the full range of field sizes; errors for multiple non-coplanar beam treatment plans are expected to be smaller. Treatment plans were generated for 19 cases using the Iris Collimator (12 field sizes) and also using one and three fixed collimators. The results of the treatment planning study demonstrate that the use of multiple field sizes achieves multiple plan quality improvements, including reduction of total MU, increase of target volume coverage and improvements in conformality and homogeneity compared with using a single field size for a large proportion of the cases studied. The Iris Collimator offers the potential to greatly increase the clinical application of multiple field sizes for robotic radiosurgery.
使用多个圆形准直器的机器人放射外科手术可以提高治疗计划质量并减少总监测单位(MU)。虹膜准直器的原理是在治疗过程中允许改变射野大小,这样通过在单次扫描中使每束射线以任意所需射野大小进行照射,就能在不增加治疗时间(因准直器更换或机器人操纵器多次遍历)的情况下实现多射野大小治疗的益处。本文介绍了虹膜可变孔径准直器(美国加利福尼亚州桑尼维尔市的Accuray公司),它由两组每组六个的钨铜合金片组成,共12个。两组相互之间旋转30度,这限制了准直器片之间的辐射泄漏,并产生一个十二边形的治疗射束。该射束近似圆形,在50%剂量半径处的均方根(rms)偏差<0.8%(对应于60mm射野大小处<0.25mm),在5mm射野大小处20 - 80%半影宽度的rms变化约为0.1mm,在60mm处增加到约0.5mm。测得的准直器最大泄漏剂量率为0.07%。描述了一种调试方法,基于等剂量线随方位角变化的周期性,通过在每个深度进行四次轮廓测量可获得平均剂量分布。平均轮廓的半影随射野大小增加,通常比等效的固定圆形准直器大0.2 - 0.6mm。在下组,孔径重复性≤0.1mm,在距射束焦点800mm的标称治疗距离处发散至≤0.2mm。输出因子(OFs)和组织模体比数据与固定准直器使用的数据相同,只是虹膜准直器的两个最小射野大小(5和7.5mm)的OFs要低得多。如果使用平均准直器轮廓,对于全范围射野大小的单束射线,圆形对称假设导致的剂量计算误差<1mm或<1%;对于多个非共面射束治疗计划,预计误差会更小。使用虹膜准直器(12个射野大小)以及分别使用一个和三个固定准直器为19个病例生成了治疗计划。治疗计划研究结果表明,与在大部分研究病例中使用单一射野大小相比,使用多个射野大小可实现多个计划质量的提升,包括减少总MU、增加靶区覆盖范围以及改善适形性和均匀性。虹膜准直器为大幅增加机器人放射外科手术中多个射野大小的临床应用提供了潜力。