Pickett Kate E, Shaw Richard J, Atkin Karl, Kiernan Kathleen E, Wilkinson Richard G
University of York, York, North Yorkshire, UK.
Soc Sci Med. 2009 Nov;69(10):1476-83. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2009.08.031. Epub 2009 Sep 16.
Studies have suggested that members of ethnic minority groups might be healthier when they live in areas with a high concentration of people from their own ethnic group - in spite of higher levels of material deprivation typically found within such areas. We investigated the effects of area-level same-ethnic density on maternal and infant health, independent of area deprivation and individual socioeconomic status, in five ethnic minority groups. The study was a cross-sectional analysis within the UK Millennium Cohort Study and included mothers in five ethnic minority groups (Black African n=367, Bangladeshi n=369, Black Caribbean n=252, Indian n=462 and Pakistani n=868) and their 9-month-old infants. Outcome measures included: low birth weight, preterm delivery, maternal depression, self-rated health and limiting long-standing illness. Compared to those who live in areas with less than 5% of people from the same-ethnic minority population, Indian and Pakistani mothers were significantly less likely to report ever being depressed in areas with high same-ethnic density. There was a protective effect of ethnic density for limiting long-term illness among Bangladeshi mothers at 5-30% density and Pakistani mothers at all higher densities. Ethnic density was unrelated to infant outcomes and maternal self-rated health, and unrelated to any outcomes in Black African and Black Caribbean mothers and infants, possibly because no families in these groups lived at higher levels of same-ethnic density. Results were similar whether we examined smaller or larger residential areas. We conclude that, among ethnic minority mothers and infants in England, the relationship of ethnic density to health varies by ethnicity and outcome. For some measures of maternal health, in some ethnic groups, the psychosocial advantages of shared culture, social networks and social capital may override the adverse effects of material deprivation.
研究表明,少数族裔群体成员生活在本族裔人口高度集中的地区时,可能会更健康——尽管这些地区通常物质匮乏程度更高。我们调查了地区层面的同种族密度对五个少数族裔群体母婴健康的影响,该影响独立于地区贫困和个人社会经济地位。这项研究是对英国千禧队列研究的横断面分析,纳入了五个少数族裔群体的母亲(非洲黑人n = 367、孟加拉人n = 369、加勒比黑人n = 252、印度人n = 462和巴基斯坦人n = 868)及其9个月大的婴儿。结果指标包括:低出生体重、早产、母亲抑郁、自评健康状况以及长期存在的限制性疾病。与生活在同种族少数族裔人口比例低于5%地区的人相比,印度和巴基斯坦母亲在同种族密度高的地区报告曾患抑郁症的可能性显著降低。在密度为5%至30%时,种族密度对孟加拉母亲以及在所有更高密度下对巴基斯坦母亲限制长期疾病具有保护作用。种族密度与婴儿健康结果和母亲自评健康状况无关,与非洲黑人及加勒比黑人母亲和婴儿的任何健康结果均无关,这可能是因为这些群体中没有家庭生活在同种族密度更高的地区。无论我们研究的是较小还是较大的居住区,结果都相似。我们得出结论,在英格兰的少数族裔母亲和婴儿中,表示种族密度与健康之间的关系因种族和健康结果而异有所不同。对于某些母亲健康指标,在某些种族群体中共享文化、社会网络和社会资本的心理社会优势可能会超过物质匮乏的不利影响。