Flavor System & Technology Laboratory, R&D Control Division, Ogawa & Co., Ltd, 15-7 Chidori Urayashu-shi, Chiba 279-0032, Japan.
Chem Senses. 2009 Nov;34(9):753-61. doi: 10.1093/chemse/bjp062. Epub 2009 Sep 22.
People are often able to reliably detect a mixture of 2 or more odorants, even if they cannot reliably detect the individual mixture components when presented individually. This phenomenon has been called mixture agonism. However, for some mixtures, agonism among mixture components is greater in barely detectable mixtures than in more easily detectable mixtures (level dependence). Most studies that have used rigorous methods have focused on simple, 2-component (binary) mixtures. The current work takes the next logical step to study detection of 3-component (ternary) mixtures. Psychometric functions were measured for 5 unmixed compounds and for 3 ternary mixtures of these compounds (2 of 5, forced-choice method). Experimenters used air dilution olfactometry to precisely control the duration and concentration of stimuli and used gas chromatography/mass spectrometry to verify vapor-phase concentrations. For 2 of the 3 mixtures, agonism was approximately additive in general agreement with similar work on binary mixtures. A third mixture was no more detectable than the most detectable component, demonstrating a lack of agonism. None of the 3 mixtures showed evidence of level dependence. Agonism may be common in ternary mixtures, but general rules of mixture interaction have yet to emerge. For now, detection of any mixture must be measured empirically.
人们通常能够可靠地检测到 2 种或多种气味剂的混合物,即使当它们单独呈现时,人们也无法可靠地检测到个别混合物成分。这种现象被称为混合物协同作用。然而,对于某些混合物,混合物成分之间的协同作用在难以察觉的混合物中比在更容易察觉的混合物中更大(水平依赖性)。大多数使用严格方法的研究都集中在简单的、2 种成分(二元)混合物上。目前的工作是朝着研究 3 种成分(三元)混合物的检测迈出的下一个合乎逻辑的步骤。对 5 种未混合的化合物和这些化合物的 3 种三元混合物(5 种中的 2 种,强制选择法)进行了心理物理函数测量。实验人员使用空气稀释嗅觉法精确控制刺激的持续时间和浓度,并使用气相色谱/质谱法验证气相浓度。对于 3 种混合物中的 2 种,协同作用大致是相加的,这与二元混合物的类似工作一致。第三种混合物的可检测性并不比最易检测的成分高,表明缺乏协同作用。这 3 种混合物都没有表现出水平依赖性的迹象。协同作用可能在三元混合物中很常见,但混合物相互作用的一般规则尚未出现。目前,任何混合物的检测都必须通过经验进行测量。