Peterson Lars E
Department of Family Medicine, Medical University of South Carolina, North Charleston.
Qual Manag Health Care. 2009 Oct-Dec;18(4):257-67. doi: 10.1097/QMH.0b013e3181bee1ce.
The content and spectrum of rural health care services are different from those in urban areas. The extent to which health care consumers' perceptions of the quality of these services vary across settings and the association of these perceptions with features of rural and urban settings are unclear.
To determine whether perceptual differences of quality exist and contrast rural/urban associations between contextual characteristics and perceived quality of health care.
Multilevel, cross-sectional analysis of a state-representative sample of 33 786 adults, stratified by rural/urban status linked with county-level data describing contextual features (eg, health care, economics, and social capital). The dependent variable was respondents' perceived quality of health care received in the past year. Weighted multilevel random intercept models examined the independent association of contextual characteristics with perceived quality.
Overall perceived quality did not differ between rural and urban settings. Similarly, the pattern of associations between perceived quality and contextual characteristics was generally comparable between settings. A notable difference was an association between higher quality with an increasing proportion of hospitals offering more than 25 services in urban areas (beta = .763; P < .05).
Despite rural/urban differences in contextual characteristics with potential influence on health care delivery, overall consumer perception of health care quality was similar in both settings. This suggests that health care managers may be adopting setting-specific strategies to enhance consumer satisfaction despite contextual differences.
农村医疗服务的内容和范围与城市地区不同。医疗保健消费者对这些服务质量的认知在不同环境中的差异程度以及这些认知与农村和城市环境特征的关联尚不清楚。
确定质量认知差异是否存在,并对比农村/城市环境特征与医疗保健感知质量之间的关联。
对33786名成年人的州代表性样本进行多层次横断面分析,按农村/城市状况分层,并与描述环境特征(如医疗保健、经济和社会资本)的县级数据相关联。因变量是受访者对过去一年接受的医疗保健质量的感知。加权多层次随机截距模型检验了环境特征与感知质量之间的独立关联。
农村和城市环境中总体感知质量没有差异。同样,不同环境中感知质量与环境特征之间的关联模式总体上具有可比性。一个显著差异是,在城市地区,提供超过25项服务的医院比例增加与更高质量之间存在关联(β = 0.763;P < 0.05)。
尽管农村/城市在可能影响医疗服务提供的环境特征方面存在差异,但两个环境中消费者对医疗保健质量的总体认知相似。这表明,尽管存在环境差异,医疗保健管理者可能正在采取针对特定环境的策略来提高消费者满意度。