Peker Ilkay, Gungor Kahraman, Semiz Mustafa, Tekdemir Ibrahim
Department of Oral Diagnosis and Radiology, Gazi University, School of Dental Medicine, Ankara, Turkey.
Coll Antropol. 2009 Sep;33(3):857-62.
The purpose of this study was to compare the efficiency of conventional and digital panoramic images for localization of mental and mandibular foramens. Six dry edentulous human mandibles were used in the study. Conventional and digital panoramic images were obtained and the vertical and horizontal measurements were performed for localization of mental and mandibular foramens on the images. The correlations between radiographic (conventional and digital) and direct measurements were compared. A measurement error between the radiographic and direct measurements was determined at the level of 1 mm. The measurement errors were generally less in conventional panoramic radiography than digital one. There was statistically strong positive correlation between direct and radiographic measurements. Statistically significant difference was found between radiographic and direct measurements for bone height of mandible in ramus region. According to the results of this study, diagnostic performance of conventional and digital panoramic images seems to be equal for the localization of mental and mandibular foramens. The vertical radiographic measurements are generally reliable and correlated with direct measurements in mandible for conventional and digital panoramic radiography, but the evaluation of bone height in ramus region may not be sufficiently reliable.
本研究的目的是比较传统全景图像和数字全景图像在颏孔和下颌孔定位方面的效率。本研究使用了六个无牙的干燥人类下颌骨。获取了传统全景图像和数字全景图像,并对图像上的颏孔和下颌孔进行了垂直和水平测量。比较了放射成像(传统和数字)测量与直接测量之间的相关性。确定了放射成像测量与直接测量之间在1毫米水平的测量误差。传统全景放射摄影中的测量误差通常比数字全景放射摄影中的小。直接测量与放射成像测量之间存在统计学上的强正相关。在下颌支区域下颌骨的骨高度方面,放射成像测量与直接测量之间存在统计学上的显著差异。根据本研究的结果,传统全景图像和数字全景图像在颏孔和下颌孔定位方面的诊断性能似乎相当。对于传统和数字全景放射摄影,垂直放射成像测量通常是可靠的,并且与下颌骨的直接测量相关,但在下颌支区域骨高度的评估可能不够可靠。