Dartmouth College, Hanover, NH, USA.
J Cogn Neurosci. 2010 Nov;22(11):2627-37. doi: 10.1162/jocn.2009.21399.
Because number is an abstract quality of a set, the way in which a number is externally represented does not change its quantitative meaning. In this study, we examined the development of the brain regions that support format-independent representation of numerical magnitude. We asked children and adults to perform both symbolic (Hindu-Arabic numerals) and nonsymbolic (arrays of squares) numerical comparison tasks as well as two control tasks while their brains were scanned using fMRI. In a preliminary analysis, we calculated the conjunction between symbolic and nonsymbolic numerical comparison. We then examined in which brain regions this conjunction differed between children and adults. This analysis revealed a large network of visual and parietal regions that showed greater activation in adults relative to children. In our primary analysis, we examined age-related differences in the conjunction of symbolic and nonsymbolic comparison after subtracting the control tasks. This analysis revealed a much more limited set of regions including the right inferior parietal lobe near the intraparietal sulcus. In addition to showing increased activation to both symbolic and nonsymbolic magnitudes over and above activation related to response selection, this region showed age-related differences in the distance effect. Our findings demonstrate that the format-independent representation of numerical magnitude in the right inferior parietal lobe is the product of developmental processes of cortical specialization and highlight the importance of using appropriate control tasks when conducting developmental neuroimaging studies.
因为数字是一个集合的抽象性质,所以数字的外部表示方式不会改变其数量意义。在这项研究中,我们研究了支持数值大小格式独立表示的大脑区域的发展。我们要求儿童和成人在进行 fMRI 扫描的同时,分别执行符号(印度-阿拉伯数字)和非符号(正方形排列)的数值比较任务,以及两个控制任务。在初步分析中,我们计算了符号和非符号数值比较之间的结合。然后,我们研究了在儿童和成人之间,这种结合在哪些大脑区域有所不同。这个分析揭示了一个包括视觉和顶叶区域的大型网络,在成人中比在儿童中表现出更强的激活。在我们的主要分析中,我们在减去控制任务后,检查了符号和非符号比较的结合在年龄上的差异。这个分析揭示了一个更有限的区域集,包括靠近顶内沟的右顶下叶。除了在反应选择相关激活的基础上,显示出对符号和非符号数量的激活增加之外,这个区域还显示出距离效应的年龄差异。我们的研究结果表明,右顶下叶中数值大小的格式独立表示是大脑皮层特化的发展过程的产物,并强调了在进行发展神经影像学研究时使用适当的控制任务的重要性。