Juste Ramon A, Alonso-Hearn Marta, Molina Elena, Geijo Marivi, Vazquez Patricia, Sevilla Iker A, Garrido Joseba M
Department of Animal Health, NEIKER-Tecnalia, Berreaga 1 E-48160 Derio, Bizkaia, Spain.
BMC Res Notes. 2009 Nov 22;2:233. doi: 10.1186/1756-0500-2-233.
Paratuberculosis vaccination has been in use in some regions for many decades, but results have not been widely spread. A new Mycobacterium avium subsp. paratuberculosis (MAP) killed vaccine was studied in relationship with its effects on fecal shedding and milk production in four farms while other two were kept as controls submitted to a test and cull scheme.
Fecal detection (n = 1829) and milking records (n = 2413) have been analyzed after two (5 herds) and four (1 herd) years of the beginning of the intervention. Shedder prevalence was reduced by 100% in three of the four vaccinated farms, 68% in the total of vaccinated animals and 46% in the two control farms. Total amount of MAP shed was reduced 77% in the vaccinated farms and 94% in the control farms. Overall milk production increased up to 3.9% after vaccination, while there was no significant difference in production after intervention in the non-vaccinated farms.
MAP shedding reduction can be quickly accomplished both by vaccination and by testing and culling. However, vaccination appears to be a less expensive and more sustainable strategy since it required one single intervention and was also associated with an increase in milk production.
副结核疫苗接种在一些地区已使用数十年,但结果尚未广泛传播。一种新的鸟分枝杆菌副结核亚种(MAP)灭活疫苗在四个农场中进行了研究,观察其对粪便排菌和产奶量的影响,同时将另外两个农场作为对照,实施检测和扑杀计划。
在干预开始两年(5个畜群)和四年(1个畜群)后,分析了粪便检测结果(n = 1829)和挤奶记录(n = 2413)。四个接种疫苗的农场中有三个农场的排菌流行率降低了100%,接种疫苗的动物总体降低了68%,两个对照农场降低了46%。接种疫苗的农场中MAP的总排菌量减少了77%,对照农场减少了94%。接种疫苗后,总体产奶量提高了3.9%,而未接种疫苗的农场在干预后的产奶量没有显著差异。
通过接种疫苗以及检测和扑杀都可以迅速减少MAP排菌。然而,接种疫苗似乎是一种成本较低且更可持续的策略,因为它只需要一次干预,并且还与产奶量增加有关。