School of Psychology, University of Queensland, Brisbane, Qld 4072, Australia.
Behav Brain Res. 2010 Dec 31;215(2):292-8. doi: 10.1016/j.bbr.2009.11.044. Epub 2009 Dec 3.
If episodic memory is an adaptation, it must have evolved to benefit present or future survival and reproduction, rather than to provide an accurate record of the past per se. Recent research has documented various links between the ability to construct episodes of the past and imagine potential future episodes, and it has been argued that the former may be a design feature of the latter. Thus, claims about the existence of episodic memory in non-verbal organisms may be evaluated by examining behavioural evidence for foresight. Here we review recent data on foresight in animals and conclude that the evidence to suggest episodic memory so far is equivocal. We suggest specific experimental criteria that could provide stronger evidence. We maintain that there must be uniquely human traits for which there are no animal models and it remains possible that mental time travel depends on several such traits. Identification of what precisely is unique about the human capacity and what is not, can inform us about the nature and evolution of the human capacities.
如果情景记忆是一种适应,那么它一定是为了有利于现在或未来的生存和繁殖而进化的,而不是为了准确记录过去本身。最近的研究记录了构建过去的情景和想象潜在未来情景的能力之间的各种联系,并有人认为前者可能是后者的设计特征。因此,关于非语言生物存在情景记忆的说法,可以通过检查对未来的前瞻性的行为证据来评估。在这里,我们回顾了动物前瞻性的最新数据,并得出结论,到目前为止,表明存在情景记忆的证据尚无定论。我们提出了具体的实验标准,可以提供更强有力的证据。我们认为,对于那些没有动物模型的独特的人类特质,仍然有可能心智时间旅行取决于几种这样的特质。确定人类能力中哪些是独特的,哪些不是独特的,可以使我们了解人类能力的性质和进化。