Alopecia Areata Patient Organization, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Am J Clin Dermatol. 2010;11(1):11-20. doi: 10.2165/11530040-000000000-00000.
Alopecia areata is an unpredictable hair-loss condition. As there is no cure for alopecia areata and no effective conventional therapy, a substantial number of alopecia areata patients resort to complementary and alternative medical remedies and therapies (CAM). This review on the application of CAM in alopecia areata addresses two pertinent aspects. First, it provides a current overview of the published medical literature on CAM used in alopecia areata, and alopecia areata-related studies. Second, it presents a thorough assessment of the considerations and limitations of the use of CAM for the treatment of alopecia areata. A systematic MEDLINE search yielded 13 studies of the clinical use of CAM in the management of alopecia areata, all belonging to one of the five main categories of CAM. Methodological quality was analyzed using objective assessment scores (Wilson and Lawrence scores). Unfortunately, no study was of sufficient internal validity to provide robust evidence of the benefit of CAM. This might be attributable to several specific disease characteristics of alopecia areata, which require an especially solid trial design to properly assess the therapeutic effects of CAM. The review concludes with some recommendations for improving the quality of trials incorporating CAM in the treatment of alopecia areata.
斑秃是一种不可预测的脱发疾病。由于目前尚无斑秃的治愈方法,也没有有效的常规疗法,因此相当数量的斑秃患者求助于补充和替代医学疗法(CAM)。本文对斑秃中应用 CAM 的研究进行了综述,涉及两个相关方面。首先,它提供了目前关于斑秃中使用的 CAM 以及斑秃相关研究的已发表医学文献的概述。其次,它全面评估了使用 CAM 治疗斑秃的注意事项和局限性。系统的 MEDLINE 搜索共获得了 13 项关于 CAM 在斑秃管理中的临床应用的研究,均属于 CAM 的五个主要类别之一。使用客观评估评分(Wilson 和 Lawrence 评分)分析了方法学质量。不幸的是,没有一项研究具有足够的内部有效性,无法为 CAM 的益处提供可靠的证据。这可能归因于斑秃的几个特定疾病特征,这需要特别坚实的试验设计才能正确评估 CAM 的治疗效果。该综述最后提出了一些建议,以提高纳入斑秃治疗中 CAM 的试验质量。