Gardner K
Rochester General Hospital, New York.
Nurs Res. 1991 Mar-Apr;40(2):113-7.
This study compared primary and team nursing in three areas: quality of care, impact on nursing staff, and cost. Eight medical units in one hospital were evaluated. The study was conducted over a four-year period utilizing three phases: one preintervention phase and two postintervention phases. The study used multiple measures including two approaches to analysis of cost. The findings of this study confirm that primary nursing does result in a higher quality of nursing care than team nursing and that nurse retention is improved in primary nursing. In addition, this study shows that, both directly and indirectly, primary nursing reduces costs when compared to team nursing.
本研究在护理质量、对护理人员的影响以及成本三个方面对责任制护理和小组护理进行了比较。对一家医院的八个医疗单元进行了评估。该研究历时四年,分三个阶段进行:一个干预前阶段和两个干预后阶段。该研究采用了多种测量方法,包括两种成本分析方法。本研究结果证实,责任制护理确实比小组护理能带来更高的护理质量,并且责任制护理能提高护士留职率。此外,本研究表明,与小组护理相比,责任制护理无论是直接还是间接都能降低成本。