Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Northwestern University and Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
PLoS Comput Biol. 2009 Dec;5(12):e1000629. doi: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1000629. Epub 2009 Dec 24.
A large number of experiments have asked to what degree human reaching movements can be understood as being close to optimal in a statistical sense. However, little is known about whether these principles are relevant for other classes of movements. Here we analyzed movement in a task that is similar to surfing or snowboarding. Human subjects stand on a force plate that measures their center of pressure. This center of pressure affects the acceleration of a cursor that is displayed in a noisy fashion (as a cloud of dots) on a projection screen while the subject is incentivized to keep the cursor close to a fixed position. We find that salient aspects of observed behavior are well-described by optimal control models where a Bayesian estimation model (Kalman filter) is combined with an optimal controller (either a Linear-Quadratic-Regulator or Bang-bang controller). We find evidence that subjects integrate information over time taking into account uncertainty. However, behavior in this continuous steering task appears to be a highly non-linear function of the visual feedback. While the nervous system appears to implement Bayes-like mechanisms for a full-body, dynamic task, it may additionally take into account the specific costs and constraints of the task.
大量实验要求在统计学意义上确定人类的伸手动作在多大程度上可以被理解为接近最优。然而,人们对于这些原则是否适用于其他类别的动作知之甚少。在这里,我们分析了类似于冲浪或滑雪板的任务中的运动。实验对象站在一个力板上,该力板测量他们的压力中心。这个压力中心会影响一个光标在投影屏幕上的加速度,光标以嘈杂的方式(如点云)显示,而实验对象则受到激励,需要将光标保持在固定位置附近。我们发现,观察到的行为的显著方面可以很好地用最优控制模型来描述,其中贝叶斯估计模型(卡尔曼滤波器)与最优控制器(线性二次调节器或 Bang-bang 控制器)相结合。我们有证据表明,实验对象会随着时间的推移整合信息,同时考虑到不确定性。然而,在这个连续转向任务中的行为似乎是视觉反馈的高度非线性函数。虽然神经系统似乎为全身、动态任务实现了类似贝叶斯的机制,但它可能还会考虑到任务的特定成本和约束。