Laboratory of Physiology, European University Miguel Ole Cervantes, Valladolid, Spain.
J Strength Cond Res. 2010 Feb;24(2):548-56. doi: 10.1519/JSC.0b013e3181c09d22.
The purpose of this meta-analysis was to attempt to gain a clear picture of the magnitude of strength improvements expected after acute and chronic vibration training and to identify specific factors that influence the treatment effects. Studies employing a strength training intervention and containing data necessary to calculate effect size (ES) were included in the analysis. A total of 31 studies met the inclusion criterion. Analysis of ES demonstrated that the type of vibration platform employed is a moderator of the treatment effect of vibration on strength development. Differences were noted in both acute and chronic changes in muscle strength when vertical vibration platforms are compared with oscillating platforms. Vertical platforms elicit a significantly larger treatment effect for chronic adaptations (ES = 1.24) compared with oscillating platforms (ES = -0.13). However, oscillating platforms elicit a greater treatment effect for acute effects (ES = 0.24) compared with vertical platforms (ES = -0.07). The data also show that gender, training status, and exercise protocol are moderators of the response to vibration exercise for strength development (vertical platforms). Based on the overall analysis, it is apparent that vibration exercise can be effective at eliciting chronic muscle strength adaptations. The vibration exercise can be used by exercise professionals to enhance muscular strength.
本荟萃分析旨在试图清晰呈现急性和慢性振动训练后预期的力量增强幅度,并确定影响治疗效果的具体因素。分析纳入了采用力量训练干预并包含有计算效应量(ES)所需数据的研究。共有 31 项研究符合纳入标准。ES 分析表明,所使用的振动平台类型是振动对力量发展影响的一个调节因素。当比较垂直振动平台和摆动平台时,在肌肉力量的急性和慢性变化方面都有差异。与摆动平台(ES = -0.13)相比,垂直平台在慢性适应方面产生的治疗效果明显更大(ES = 1.24)。然而,与垂直平台(ES = -0.07)相比,摆动平台在急性效果方面产生了更大的治疗效果(ES = 0.24)。数据还表明,性别、训练状态和运动方案是垂直平台振动运动对力量发展反应的调节因素。基于整体分析,显然振动运动可以有效地引起慢性肌肉力量适应。运动专业人员可以使用振动运动来增强肌肉力量。