Department of Communication Disorders, University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand.
Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2010 May-Jun;45(3):320-35. doi: 10.3109/13682820903003514.
Children with Down syndrome experience difficulty with both spoken and written language acquisition, however controlled intervention studies to improve these difficulties are rare and have typically focused on improving one language domain.
To investigate the effectiveness of an integrated intervention approach on the speech, letter knowledge, and phonological awareness development of ten pre-school children with Down syndrome aged between 4;4 and 5;5.
METHODS & PROCEDURES: A multiple single-subject design was used to evaluate treatment effectiveness. Baseline and intervention measures for speech and pre- and post-intervention measures for letter knowledge and phonological awareness were compared. The intervention comprised three components: a parent-implemented home programme; centre-based speech-language therapy sessions, and 'Learning through Computer' sessions with a total intervention time of 20 hours over 18 weeks. Letter knowledge and phonological awareness activities were linked to each child's speech targets.
OUTCOMES & RESULTS: Results indicated significant treatment effects on speech measures for all ten participants. Six of the ten participants showed increases on letter knowledge and nine showed increased awareness of initial phonemes in words but responses were not above binomial chance level (that is, 70% correct) for phonological awareness tasks. Individual results are presented and implications for parents and therapists are discussed.
The findings of this study suggest an intervention approach that integrates speech, letter knowledge, and phonological awareness targets is effective in remediating speech error patterns at the single-word level in young children with Down syndrome. Phonological awareness and letter knowledge appeared to be stimulated through the intervention, but significant improvement above chance levels on untrained phonological awareness tasks was not evident. Follow-up investigation is necessary to determine longer-term outcomes.
唐氏综合征患儿在口语和书面语习得方面均存在困难,但针对这些困难进行的控制性干预研究较为罕见,且通常侧重于改善一个语言领域。
调查综合干预方法对 10 名 4 岁 4 个月至 5 岁 5 个月唐氏综合征学龄前儿童的言语、字母知识和语音意识发展的有效性。
采用多个单一被试设计来评估治疗效果。将言语的基线和干预测量值与字母知识和语音意识的预干预和后干预测量值进行了比较。干预包括三个部分:家长实施的家庭方案;中心的言语语言治疗课程,以及“通过计算机学习”课程,总干预时间为 18 周的 20 小时。字母知识和语音意识活动与每个孩子的言语目标相关联。
结果表明,所有 10 名参与者的言语测量值均有显著的治疗效果。在字母知识方面,10 名参与者中有 6 名增加,在单词的初始音位意识方面,有 9 名增加,但语音意识任务的反应均未超过二项式机会水平(即 70%正确)。个别结果如下,并讨论了对家长和治疗师的启示。
本研究的结果表明,一种综合言语、字母知识和语音意识目标的干预方法在纠正唐氏综合征幼儿单词语音错误模式方面是有效的。通过干预似乎刺激了语音意识和字母知识的发展,但在未受过训练的语音意识任务中,明显提高到机会水平以上的情况并不明显。需要进行随访调查以确定长期结果。