Aziz Sina, Noorulain Wajeeha, Majid Rukhsana, Hosain Kehkashan, Siddiqui Intisar Ahmed, Manzoor Shaheena
Sarwar Zuberi Liver Centre, Dow University of Health Sciences, Karachi.
J Coll Physicians Surg Pak. 2010 Jan;20(1):10-6.
To compare the dietary pattern, height, weight centile and BMI of affluent school children and adolescents from three major cities of Pakistan.
Cross-sectional study.
Private Schools of Karachi, Quetta and Lahore, from September 2007 to March 2008.
The affluent socioeconomic group was identified by the monthly income of the parents (average>Rs.15,000 per month, $246); school fees of child (average>Rs.1,500 per month, $25) and household items such as computer, refrigerator, washing machine, television, car etc. A total of 652 healthy immunized children with no history of chronic infection, inducted through multistage stratified sampling were divided into groups A, B, and C by ages of 6-9, 10-13, and 14-17 years respectively. Height, weight and 24 hours diet recall was obtained. Centre for Disease Control and prevention (CDC), clinical charts with 5th and 95 percentile for standard height and weight were used. Food records subjected to USDA food exchange list were used. Forms were used as inputs to generate tables for Statistical Package for social sciences -SPSS, Window 13.0.
In girls calories and food intake in group A and B of Quetta was lower (p<.005) vs. other cities. No significant difference was seen in group C. Fat intake was the same in the girls of all 3 groups. In boys caloric carbohydrates and protein intake of group A of Quetta vs. groups B and C was significant by different National Centre for Health Statistics (NCHS) height and weight in groups A and B were at the 50-90 centile and at 25-50 in group C, centile. BMI (kg/m2) in girls and boys of group A were not different. BMI was highest in group B girls (mean 22+/-5) and group C boys (25+/-4) of Quetta.
Children of affluent schools of Karachi compared to Quetta are taking more junk food but their consumption of protein is lowered and of a poor quality. Overall fat is below normal recommended standards. However, minimum fat intake was seen in school children of Quetta when compared with Karachi and Lahore. Carbohydrate consumption was adequate. BMI was highest in boys of Quetta than Lahore and Karachi. Majority of children on NCHS centile charts plotted between the 50th-90th centiles.
比较巴基斯坦三个主要城市富裕家庭学童及青少年的饮食模式、身高、体重百分位数和体重指数。
横断面研究。
2007年9月至2008年3月,卡拉奇、奎达和拉合尔的私立学校。
根据父母月收入(平均>15,000卢比/月,246美元)、孩子学费(平均>1,500卢比/月,25美元)以及电脑、冰箱、洗衣机、电视、汽车等家庭用品来确定富裕社会经济群体。通过多阶段分层抽样纳入652名无慢性感染史的健康免疫儿童,分别按6 - 9岁、10 - 13岁和14 - 17岁分为A、B、C组。获取身高、体重及24小时饮食回忆情况。使用疾病控制与预防中心(CDC)标准身高和体重第5和第95百分位数的临床图表。采用美国农业部食物交换表的食物记录。表格用作输入,以生成社会科学统计软件包 - SPSS(Windows 13.0)的表格。
在女孩中,奎达A组和B组的卡路里和食物摄入量低于其他城市(p <.005)。C组无显著差异。所有3组女孩的脂肪摄入量相同。在男孩中,奎达A组的热量、碳水化合物和蛋白质摄入量与B组和C组相比,根据不同的美国国家卫生统计中心(NCHS)身高和体重标准有显著差异,A组和B组处于第50 - 90百分位数,C组处于第25 - 50百分位数。A组女孩和男孩的体重指数(kg/m²)无差异。奎达B组女孩(平均22±5)和C组男孩(25±4)的体重指数最高。
与奎达相比,卡拉奇富裕学校的儿童摄入更多垃圾食品,但蛋白质摄入量降低且质量较差。总体脂肪低于正常推荐标准。然而与卡拉奇和拉合尔相比,奎达学童的脂肪摄入量最低。碳水化合物摄入量充足。奎达男孩的体重指数高于拉合尔和卡拉奇。大多数儿童在美国国家卫生统计中心百分位数图表上处于第50 - 90百分位数之间。