Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering and Coordinated Science Laboratory, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Urbana-Champaign, IL, USA.
Sci Eng Ethics. 2010 Mar;16(1):201-15. doi: 10.1007/s11948-010-9195-5. Epub 2010 Feb 10.
How can a course on engineering ethics affect an undergraduate student's feelings of responsibility about moral problems? In this study, three groups of students were interviewed: six students who had completed a specific course on engineering ethics, six who had registered for the course but had not yet started it, and six who had not taken or registered for the course. Students were asked what they would do as the central character, an engineer, in each of two short cases that posed moral problems. For each case, the role of the engineer was successively changed and the student was asked how each change altered his or her decisions about the case. Students who had completed the ethics course considered more options before making a decision, and they responded consistently despite changes in the cases. For both cases, even when they were not directly involved, they were more likely to feel responsible and take corrective action. Students who were less successful in the ethics course gave answers similar to students who had not taken the course. This latter group of students seemed to have weaker feelings of responsibility: they would say that a problem was "not my business." It appears that instruction in ethics can increase awareness of responsibility, knowledge about how to handle a difficult situation, and confidence in taking action.
工科伦理课程如何影响本科生对道德问题的责任感?在这项研究中,对三组学生进行了访谈:六名已完成工科伦理课程的学生、六名已注册但尚未开始该课程的学生,以及六名未修读或注册该课程的学生。学生们被要求在两个提出道德问题的短篇案例中扮演中心角色,即工程师,回答他们会怎么做。对于每个案例,工程师的角色会依次改变,学生被要求回答每个变化如何改变他们对案例的决定。完成伦理课程的学生在做出决定之前会考虑更多的选择,并且他们的回答在案例发生变化时保持一致。对于这两个案例,即使他们没有直接参与,他们也更有可能感到有责任并采取纠正措施。在伦理课程中表现不佳的学生的回答与未修读该课程的学生相似。后一组学生似乎责任感较弱:他们会说一个问题“与我无关”。似乎伦理道德方面的指导可以增强责任感,了解如何处理困难情况的知识,并增强采取行动的信心。