Persons J B
Department of Psychiatry, University of California, San Francisco.
Am Psychol. 1991 Feb;46(2):99-106. doi: 10.1037//0003-066x.46.2.99.
It is argued that the design of contemporary psychotherapy outcome studies is conceptually incompatible with the models of psychotherapy evaluated in those studies. Contemporary outcome studies are incompatible with psychotherapy models because the outcome studies treat patients with standardized treatments that are assigned on the basis of psychiatric diagnosis rather than with individualized treatments based on a theory-driven psychological assessment of the individual's difficulties. One possible remedy, idiographic outcome studies using a case formulation model of assessment and treatment, is proposed here. It is suggested that this research strategy may narrow the scientist-practitioner gap and make it easier to demonstrate differential outcomes of different treatments.
有人认为,当代心理治疗疗效研究的设计在概念上与这些研究中所评估的心理治疗模型不兼容。当代疗效研究与心理治疗模型不兼容,因为疗效研究采用基于精神科诊断分配的标准化治疗来治疗患者,而不是基于对个体困难的理论驱动的心理评估进行个性化治疗。本文提出了一种可能的补救方法,即使用评估和治疗的个案构思模型进行个案研究。有人认为,这种研究策略可能会缩小科学家与从业者之间的差距,并使展示不同治疗方法的差异疗效变得更容易。