Mediterranean Institute of Cognitive Neurosciences, CNRS and Aix-Marseille University, and fMRI Centre, Timone Hospital, Marseille, France.
Neuroimage. 2010 May 15;51(1):450-61. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2010.02.023. Epub 2010 Feb 13.
Two fMRI experiments were conducted using song to investigate the domain specificity of linguistic and musical processing. In Experiment 1, participants listened to pairs of spoken words, "vocalise" (i.e., singing without words), and sung words while performing a same-different task. Results revealed bilateral involvement of middle and superior temporal gyri and inferior and middle frontal gyri while listening to spoken words, sung words and vocalise, although to different degrees. In Experiment 2, participants listened to pairs of sung words that were similar or different in terms of the linguistic and musical dimensions (2x2 factorial event-related design) while performing a same-different task. Results showed widespread interactions between the linguistic and musical dimensions of sung words mainly within the network of brain areas identified in Experiment 1. Consequently, the activity in these brain regions cannot be considered as specific to either language or music processing. Taken together, results of both experiments argue against domain specificity and provide additional evidence for a common cerebral network involved in both lexical/phonological and melodic processing.
进行了两项 fMRI 实验,使用歌曲来研究语言和音乐处理的领域特异性。在实验 1 中,参与者在执行相同-不同任务时听了一对口语词“发声”(即无词唱歌)和唱词。结果显示,在听口语词、唱词和发声时,双侧中颞回和下、中额回都有参与,尽管参与程度不同。在实验 2 中,参与者在执行相同-不同任务时听了一对在语言和音乐维度上相似或不同的唱词(2x2 因子相关设计)。结果显示,唱词的语言和音乐维度之间存在广泛的相互作用,主要在实验 1 中确定的脑区网络内。因此,这些脑区的活动不能被认为是专门用于语言或音乐处理的。总之,这两项实验的结果都反对领域特异性,并提供了更多证据表明在处理词汇/音韵和旋律方面涉及共同的大脑网络。