National Drug Research Institute, Curtin University of Technology, Perth, WA 6845, Australia.
Accid Anal Prev. 2010 Mar;42(2):637-44. doi: 10.1016/j.aap.2009.10.010. Epub 2009 Nov 11.
This paper presents qualitative data from an in-depth interview study of 40 repeat drink drivers in Perth Western Australia to inform countermeasures for these high risk offenders.
Licence sanctions are effective countermeasures for most drink drivers but the small group of repeat offenders are less responsive. Many choose to drive whilst unlicensed as the probability of detection is low and the social and economic costs of not driving can be high. This undermines other drink drive countermeasures.
Most respondents who had had their licence suspended admitted to driving whilst under suspension. Employment and social factors were key themes emerging in respondents' accounts of driving whilst under licence suspension.
Whilst a range of enforcement countermeasures are needed to deter drunk and unlicensed driving, this study suggests that where possible we aim to keep offenders within the system that consists of formal laws and informal social controls, rather than apply penalties in ways that undermine adherence to the law by increasing unlicensed driving. Allowing for interlock installation early in the driving suspension period, and allowing fines to offset cost of interlock installation and monitoring, may maximise community benefit and reduce unlicensed driving.
本文呈现了对澳大利亚珀斯 40 名多次酒后驾车者进行深入访谈研究的定性数据,以期为这些高风险违法者提供对策。
吊销驾照是大多数酒后驾车者的有效对策,但一小部分多次违法者对此反应不大。许多人选择在无照驾驶,因为被发现的概率很低,而且不驾驶的社会和经济成本可能很高。这破坏了其他酒后驾车对策。
大多数因驾照被吊销而承认在吊销期间驾驶的受访者都是这样做的。就业和社会因素是受访者在驾照吊销期间驾驶的叙述中出现的关键主题。
虽然需要采取一系列执法对策来阻止醉酒和无照驾驶,但本研究表明,在可能的情况下,我们的目标是让违法者留在由正式法律和非正式社会控制组成的系统中,而不是通过增加无照驾驶来破坏对法律的遵守,从而适用处罚。在驾驶停驶期间尽早允许安装酒精锁,并允许罚款来抵消酒精锁安装和监控的费用,可能会最大限度地提高社区效益并减少无照驾驶。